Excursus on the
Conciliabulum Styling Itself the Seventh Ecumenical Council, But
Commonly Called the Mock Synod of Constantinople.
a.d.
754.
The
reader will find all the
information he desires with regard to the great iconoclastic
controversy in the ordinary church-histories, and the theological side
of the matter in the writings of St. John Damascene. It seems,
however, that in order to render the meaning of the action of the last
of the Ecumenical Councils clear it is necessary to provide an account
of the synod which was held to condemn what it so shortly afterward
expressly approved. I quote from Hefele
in loco
, and would
only further draw the reader’s attention to the fact that the
main thing objected to was not (as is commonly supposed) the outward
veneration of the sacred icons, but the making and setting up of them,
as architectural ornaments; and that it was not only representations of
the persons of the Most Holy Trinity, and of the Divine Son in his
incarnate form that were denounced, but even pictures of the Blessed
Virgin and of the other saints; all this is evident to anyone reading
the foregoing abstract of the decree.
(Hefele,
History
of the Councils
, Vol. V., p. 308
et seqq
.)
The Emperor, after the death of the Patriarch Anastasius
(
a.d.
753), summoned the bishops of his Empire
to a great synod in the palace Hieria, which lay opposite to
Constantinople on the Asiatic side of the Bosphorus, between
Chrysopolis and Chalcedon, a little to the north of the latter.
The vacancy of the patriarchate, facilitated his plans, since the hope
of succeeding to this see kept down, in the most ambitious and aspiring
of the bishops, any possible thought of opposition. The number of
those present amounted to 338 bishops, and the place of president was
occupied by Archbishop Theodosius of Ephesus, already known to us as
son of a former Emperor—Apsimar, from the beginning an assistant
in the iconoclastic movement. Nicephorus names him alone as
president of the synod; Theophanes, on the contrary, mentions Bishop
Pastillas of Perga as second president, and adds, “The
Patriarchates of Rome, Alexandria, Antioch, and Jerusalem were not
represented [the last three were then in the hands of the Saracens],
the transactions began on February 10th, and lasted until August 8th
(in Hieria); on the latter date, however, the synod assembled in St.
Mary’s Church in Blachernæ, the northern suburb of
Constantinople, and the Emperor now solemnly nominated Bishop
Constantine of Sylæum, a monk, as patriarch of
Constantinople. On August 27th, the heretical decree [of the
Synod] was published.”
We see from this that the last sessions of this
Conciliabulum were held no longer in Hieria, but in the Blachernæ
of Constantinople. We have no complete Acts of this assembly, but
its very verbose
ὅρος
(decree), together with a short
introduction, is preserved among the acts of the Seventh Ecumenical
Council.
This decree was by no means suffered to remain
inoperative.
(W. M. Sinclair. Smith and Wace,
Dictionary of
Chr.
Biog., sub voce
Constantinus VI.)
The Emperor singled out the more noted monks, and
required them to comply with the decrees of the synod. In
a.d.
766 he exacted an oath against images from
all the inhabitants of the empire. The monks refused with violent
obstinacy, and Copronymus appears to have amused himself by treating
them with ruthless harshness. The Emperor, indeed, seems to have
contemplated the extirpation of monachism. John the Damascene he
persuaded his bishops to excommunicate. Monks were forced to
appear in the hippodrome at Constantinople hand in hand with harlots,
while the populace spat at them. The new patriarch Constantinus,
presented by the emperor to the council the last day of its session,
was forced to foreswear images, to attend banquets, to eat and drink
freely against his monastic vows, to wear garlands, to witness the
coarse spectacles and hear the coarse language which entertained the
Emperor. Monasteries were destroyed, made into barracks, or
secularized. Lachanodraco, governor of the Thracian Theme, seems
to have exceeded Copronymus in his ribaldry and injustice. He
collected a number of monks into a plain, clothed them with white,
presented them with wives, and forced them to choose between marriage
and loss of eyesight. He sold the property of the monasteries,
and sent the price to the Emperor. Copronymus publicly thanked
him, and commended his example to other governors.
(Harnack.
History of Dogma
, Vol. V., p. 325
[Eng. Tr.].)
The clergy obeyed when the decrees were published; but
resistance was offered in the ranks of the monks. Many took to
flight, some became martyrs. The imperial police stormed the
churches, and destroyed those images and pictures that had not been
secured. The iconoclastic zeal by no means sprang from enthusiasm
for divine service in spirit and in truth. The Emperor now also
directly attacked the monks; he meant to extirpate the hated order, and
to overthrow the throne of Peter. We see how the idea of an
absolute military state rose powerfully in Constantinople; how it
strove to establish itself by brute force. The Emperor, according
to trustworthy evidence, made the inhabitants of the city swear
that they would henceforth worship
no image, and give up all intercourse with monks. Cloisters were
turned into arsenals and barracks, relics were hurled into the sea, and
the monks, as far as possible, secularized. And the politically
far-seeing Emperor, at the same time entered into correspondence with
France (Synod of Gentilly,
a.d.
767), and
sought to win Pepin. History seemed to have suffered a violent
rupture, a new era was dawning which should supersede the history of
the Church.
But the Church was too powerful, and the Emperor was not
even master of Oriental Christendom, but only of part of it. The
orthodox Patriarchs of the East (under the rule of Islam) declared
against the iconoclastic movement, and a Church without monks or
pictures, in schism with the other orthodox Churches, was a
nonentity. A spiritual reformer was wanting. Thus the great
reaction set in after the death of the Emperor (
a.d.
775), the ablest ruler Constantinople had seen for a
long time. This is not the place to describe how it was
inaugurated and cautiously carried out by the skilful policy of the
Empress Irene; cautiously, for a generation had already grown up that
was accustomed to the cultus without images. An important part
was played by the miracles performed by the re-emerging relics and
pictures. But the lower classes had always been really favourable
to them; only the army and the not inconsiderable number of bishops who
were of the school of Constantine had to be carefully handled.
Tarasius, the new Patriarch of Constantinople and a supporter of
images, succeeded, after overcoming much difficulty, and especially
distrust in Rome and the East, after also removing the excited army, in
bringing together a General Council of about 350 bishops at Nicæa,
a.d.
787, which reversed the decrees of
a.d.
754. The proceedings of the seven
sittings are of great value, because very important patristic passages
have been preserved in them which otherwise would have perished; for at
this synod also the discussions turned chiefly on the Fathers.
The decision (
ὅρος
) restored orthodoxy and
finally settled it.
I cannot do better than to cite in conclusion the words
of the profoundly learned Archbishop of Dublin, himself a
quasi-Iconoclast.
(Trench.
Lect. Medieval Ch. Hist
., p.
93.)
It is only fair to state that the most zealous favourers
and promoters of this ill-directed homage always disclaimed with
indignation the charge of offering to the images any reverence which
did not differ in kind, and not merely in degree, from the worship
which they offered to Almighty God, designating it as they did by
altogether a different name. We shall very probably feel that in
these distinctions which they drew between the one and the other,
between the “honour” which they gave to these icons and the
“worship” which they withheld from these and gave only to
God, there lay no slightest justification of that in which they allowed
themselves; but these distinctions acquit them of idolatry, and it is
the merest justice to remember this.
(Trench.
Ut supra
, p. 99.)
I can close this Lecture with no better or wiser words
than those with which Dean Milman reads to us the lesson of this
mournful story: “There was this irremediable weakness in
the cause of iconoclasm; it was a mere negative doctrine, a
proscription of those sentiments which had full possession of the
popular mind, without any strong countervailing excitement. The
senses were robbed of their habitual and cherished objects of devotion,
but there was no awakening of an inner life of intense and passionate
piety. The cold, naked walls from whence the Scriptural histories
had been effaced, the despoiled shrines, the mutilated images, could
not compel the mind to a more pure and immaterial conception of God and
the Saviour. Hatred of images, in the process of the strife,
might become, as it did, a fanaticism, it could never become a
religion. Iconoclasm might proscribe idolatry; but it had no
power of kindling a purer faith.”