There is also need of a certain
amount of ‘rational considerations’ in advancing a Defence
and a Theory of Christianity. He makes this according to the special
requirements of the time in his Oratio Catechetica. His
reasonings do not seem to us always convincing; but the presence of a
living Hellenism and Judaism in the world required them. These two
phenomena also explain what appears to us a great weakness in this
work: namely, that he treats Hellenism as if it were all speculation;
Judaism as if it were all facts. These two religions were too near and
too practically opposed to each other for him to see, as we can now, by
the aid of a sort of science of religions, that every religion has its
idea, and every religion has its facts. He and all the
first Apologists, with the spectacle of these two apparently opposite
systems before them, thought that, in arriving at the True Religion as
well, all could be done by considering facts; or all could be
done by speculation. Gregory chose the latter method. A Dogmatic
in the modern sense, in which both the idea and the facts of
Christianity flow into one, could not have been expected of him. The
Oratio Catechetica is a mere philosophy of Christianity in
detail written in the philosophic language of the time. Not only does
he refrain from using the historic proofs, i.e. of prophecy and type
(except very sparingly and only to meet an adversary), but his defence
is insufficient from another point of view also; he hardly uses the
moral proofs either; he wanders persistently in metaphysics.