A
similar suggestion had been already made by Dionysius in the passage
quoted by Eusebius in Bk. VII. chap. 25, and Eusebius was undoubtedly
thinking of it when he wrote these words. The suggestion is a very
clever one, and yet it is only a guess, and does not pretend to be
more. Dionysius concludes that the Apocalypse must have been written by
some person named John, because it testifies to that fact itself; but
the style, and other internal indications, lead him to think that it
cannot have been written by the author of the fourth Gospel, whom he
assumes to be John the apostle. He is therefore led to suppose that the
Apocalypse was written by some other John. He does not pretend to say
who that John was, but thinks it must have been some John that resided
in Asia; and he then adds that there were said to be two tombs in
Ephesus bearing the name of John,—evidently implying, though he
does not say it, that he is inclined to think that this second John
thus commemorated was the author of the Apocalypse. It is plain from
this that he had no tradition whatever in favor of this theory, that it
was solely an hypothesis arising from critical difficulties standing in
the way of the ascription of the book to the apostle John. Eusebius
sees in this suggestion a very welcome solution of the difficulties
with which he feels the acceptance of the book to be beset, and at once
states it as a possibility that this “presbyter John,” whom
he has discovered in the writings of Papias, may have been the author
of the book. But the authenticity of the Apocalypse was too firmly
established to be shaken by such critical and theological difficulties
as influenced Dionysius, Eusebius, and a few others, and in consequence
nothing came of the suggestion made here by Eusebius. In the present
century, however, the “presbyter John” has again played an
important part among some critics as the possible author of certain of
the Johannine writings, though the authenticity of the Apocalypse has
(until very recently) been so commonly accepted even by the most
negative critics that the “presbyter John” has not figured
at all as the author of it; nor indeed is he likely to in the
future.