true. Therefore it is absurd (not to say worse) to talk of any divine institution, leading us
thus to judge. It would be to suppose, that God by his institution has made that judgment
rational, which he at the same time makes improbable, and therefore irrational.
This notion of admitting members into the church of Christ without and against prob-
ability of true piety, is not only very inconsistent with itself, but very inconsistent with what
the common light of mankind teaches in their dealings one with another. Common sense
teaches all mankind, in admission of members into societies, at least societies formed for
very great and important purposes, to admit none but those concerning whom there is an
apparent probability, that they are the hearty friends of the society, and of the main designs
and interests of it; and especially not to admit such concerning whom there is a greater
probability of their being habitual fixed enemies. But thus it is, according to Mr. S.‘s and
Mr. W.‘s doctrine, as well as the doctrine of the Scripture, with all unsanctified men, in regard
to the church of Christ. They are enemies to the head of the society, enemies to his honour
and authority, and the work of salvation in the way of the gospel; the upholding and pro-
moting of which is the main design of the society. The church is represented in Scripture
as the household of God, in a peculiar manner intrusted with the care of his name and honour
in the world, the interests of his kingdom, the care of his jewels, and most precious things.
And would not common sense teach an earthly prince not to admit into his household, such
as he had no reason to look upon so much as probable friends and loyal subjects in their
hearts; but rather friends and slaves in their hearts to his enemies and competitors for his
crown and dignity? The visible church of Christ is often represented as his city and his army.
Now would not common sense teach the inhabitants of a besieged city to open the gates to
none, but those concerning whom there is at least an apparent probability of their not being
enemies? And would any imagine, that in a militant state of things it is a likely way to promote
the interest of the war, to fill up the army with such as are more likely to be on the enemies’
side in their hearts, than on the side of their lawful and rightful prince, and his faithful soldiers
and subjects.
1943
SECTION VI. Visibility without probability.