The two together ‘are, next to
Origen’s de Principiis, the first attempt to construct a
scientific system of the Christian religion upon certain fundamental
ideas of God and world, sin and redemption; and they form the ripe
fruit of the positive apology in the Greek Church.’ (Schaff,
Nicene Christianity, p. 82.) The polemic against idolatry and heathen
mythology is common to the general class of Christian apologists, and
is to be found in heathen writers like Lucian and even Porphyry (letter
to Anebo). But what distinguishes Athanasius from previous apologists
(excepting Origen) is the novel nature of his problem. The alliance
between philosophy and gross popular idolatry had given Christian
apology a new task. From Porphyry downwards (Porphyry himself was not
consistent in this respect) the Neo-platonist school, in alarm at the
progress of Christianity, had taken up the defence of popular paganism,
endeavouring to subsume its grosser manifestations, its images,
sacrifices, &c., under philosophico-religious principles
(infra §19, &c.). The idea of ‘theurgy’ as
the necessary initiation into the higher life colours the teaching of
Porphyry, but more strongly that of his pupil Iamblichus, who died
early in the fourth century, and whose pupils (Ædesius, &c.)
were contemporaries of Athanasius. This degeneration of Platonism,
however, went along with the continued study of Plato, whose dialogues
are to some extent common ground between Athanasius and his opponents
(Phædrus, §5, 33, Laws, 33, Timæus, 41, &c.,
&c.; but it is not in every case easy to say whether Athan. quotes
Plato merely at second hand, or directly, as he certainly does 10.
4).