to be a teacher on this subject, and to them I confess that of this, as well as of many other
things, I am ignorant, and perhaps, though they maintain a respectful demeanour in my
presence, they say among themselves: “Art thou a master in Israel, and knowest not these
things?”2726 a rebuke which the Lord gave to one who belonged to the class of men who
delighted in being called Rabbi; which was also the reason of his coming by night to the true
Teacher, because perchance he, who had been accustomed to teach, blushed to take the
learner’s place. But, for my own part, it gives me much more pleasure to hear instruction
from another, than to be myself listened to as a teacher. For I remember what He said to
those whom, above all men, He had chosen: “But be not ye called Rabbi, for one is your
master, even Christ.”2727 Nor was it any other teacher who taught Moses by Jethro,2728
Cornelius by Peter the earlier apostle,2729 and Peter himself by Paul the later apostle;2730
for by whomsoever truth is spoken, it is spoken by the gift of Him who is the Truth. What
if the reason of our still being ignorant of these things, and of our having failed to discover
them, even after praying, reading, thinking, and reasoning, be this: that full proof may be
made not only of the love with which we give instruction to the ignorant, but also of the
humility with which we receive instruction from the learned?
10. Teach me, therefore, I beseech you, what I may teach to others; teach me what I
ought to hold as my own opinion; and tell me this: if souls are from day to day made for
each individual separately at birth, where, in the case of infant children, is sin committed
by these souls, so that they require the remission of sin in the sacrament of Christ, because
of sinning in Adam from whom the sinful flesh has been derived? or if they do not sin, how
is it compatible with the justice of the Creator, that, because of their being united to mortal
members derived from another, they are so brought under the bond of the sin of that other,
that unless they be rescued by the Church, perdition overtakes them, although it is not in
their own power to secure that they be rescued by the grace of baptism? Where, therefore,
is the justice of the condemnation of so many thousands of souls, which in the deaths of
infant children leave this world without the benefit of the Christian sacrament, if being
newly created they have, not through any preceding sin of their own, but by the will of the
Creator, become severally united to the individual bodies to animate which they were created
and bestowed by Him, who certainly knew that every one of them was destined, not through
any fault of its own, to leave the body without receiving the baptism of Christ? Seeing,
therefore, that we may not say concerning God either that He compels them to become
2726 John iii. 10.
2727 Matt. xxiii. 8.
2728 Ex. xviii. 14–25.
2729 Acts x. 25–48.
2730 Gal. ii. 11–21.
1120
To Jerome