Transpositions of the terms in his own false premises;
τῶν
σοφισμάτων
ἀντιστροφὰς. The same as “the professional twisting of
premisses,” and “the hooking backward and forward and
twisting of premisses” below. The terms Father and ᾽Αγέννητος
are transposed or twisted into each other’s
place in this ‘irrefragable syllogism.’ It is ‘a
reductio ad absurdum’ thus:—
Father means ᾽Αγέννητος
(Basil’s premiss),
∴ ᾽Αγέννητος
means Father.
The fallacy of Eunomius consists
in making ‘Father’ universal in his own premiss, when it
was only particular in Basil’s. “᾽Αγέννητος
means the whole contents of the word
Father,” which therefore cannot mean having generated a son. It
is a False Conversion.
This Conversion or ἀντιοτροφὴ
is illustrated in Aristotle’s Analytics,
Prior. I. iii. 3. It is legitimate thus:—
Some B is A
∴ Some A is (some) B.