with the younger Theodosius and the great men, that he could easily throw everything into
commotion; and thus there was need of an Ecumenical Council, the question being most
important, and the person of the highest dignity; because many bishops, amongst these almost
all of the East—that is, of the Patriarchate of Antioch, and the Patriarch John himself—were
ill disposed to Cyril, and seemed to favour Nestorius: because men’s feelings were divided,
and the whole empire of the East seemed to fluctuate between Cyril and Nestorius. Such
was the need of an Ecumenical Council.
The Emperor, moved by these and other reasons, wrote to Cyril,—“It is our will that
193
the holy doctrine be discussed and examined in a sacred Synod, and that be ratified which
appeareth agreeable to the right faith, whether the wrong party be pardoned by the Fathers
or no.”
Here we see three things: First, after the judgment of St. Celestine, another is still re-
quired, that of the Council; secondly, that these two things would rest with the Fathers, to
judge of doctrine and of persons; thirdly, that the judgment of the Council would be decisive
and final. He adds, “those who everywhere preside over the Priesthood, and through whom
we ourselves are and shall be professing the truth, must be judges of this matter.” See on
whose faith we rest. See in whose judgment is the final and irreversible authority.
Both the Emperor affirmed, and the bishops confessed, that this was done according to
the Ecclesiastical Canons. And so all, and Celestine himself, prepared themselves for the
Council. Cyril does no more, though named by Celestine to execute the pontifical decree,
Nestorius remained in his original rank; the sentence of the universal Council is awaited;
and the Emperor had expressly decreed, “that before the assembling and common sentence
of the most holy Council, no change should be made in any matter at all, on any private
authority.” Rightly, and in order; for this was demanded by the majesty of an universal
Council. Wherefore, both Cyril obeyed and the bishops rested. And it was established, that
although the sentence of the Roman Pontiff on matters of Faith, and on persons judged for
violation of the Faith, had been passed and promulged, all was suspended, while the authority
of the universal Council was awaited.
Having gone over what preceded the Council, we review the acts of the Council itself,
and begin with the first course of proceeding. After, therefore, the bishops and Nestorius
himself were come to Ephesus, the universal Council began, Cyril being president, and
representing Celestine, as being appointed by the Pontiff himself to execute his sentence.
In the first course of proceeding this was done. First, the above-mentioned letter of the
Emperor was read, that an Ecumenical Council should be held, and all proceedings in the
mean time be suspended; this letter, I say, was read, and placed on the Acts, and it was ap-
proved by the Fathers, that all the decrees of Celestine in the matter of Nestorius had been
suspended until the holy Council should give its sentence. You will ask if it was the will of
the Council merely that the Emperor should be allowed to prohibit, in the interim, effect
373
Historical Introduction.