20 MEMORIALS OF TWO SISTERS [1845-7
to be on Mental Philosophy or Logic, as I think it will, and
you should wish to take part in it, and if Papa could only
be persuaded to let one of us join, I would give up my
place to you when you return.
My father consented to the lessons. The class was
arranged for Mr. Martineau, and began in October.
Catherine and I joined it at once, and Emily later
on. The subject chosen for Mr. Martineau's lectures
was Logic; but besides our studies connected with
that, he made us write essays for him on given sub-
jects, which he read aloud the week after, correcting
anything he disapproved in style or thought. This
course of lessons was not merely to us the most inter-
esting and delightful of our occupations at the time,
but formed a very important and beneficial era in the
development of our intellectual and spiritual life.
This was especially the case with Catherine. The
various influences under which she came at Dresden
had thrown her out of the old traditional grooves of
thought and feeling in which her childhood had moved,
and her whole intellectual being was now in a state
of ferment; she had entered on what the Germans
call the " Sturm und Drang Periode " of her life.
Her early beliefs had been rudely shattered, and she
was at this epoch much inclined to replace them by
the worship of Art and Culture. Goethe was her
chief instructor and guide, and her philosophy was a
chaos. Many times in later years she has told me
that it was to Mr. Martineau she owed her deliver-
ance from this state of mind, with all its dangers.
His teaching laid down for her, once for all, the
landmarks of mental and moral philosophy, which
proved her guide through all the varied schools of