1. I say then (a false inference from ch. Romans 10:19-21,—made in order to be refuted), Did ( ì Þ, it cannot surely be, that) God cast off His people (as would almost appear from the severe words just adduced)? Be it not so: for I also am an Israelite ( ἐκγένουςἸσρ., Philippians 3:5), of the seed of Abraham (mentioned probably for solemnity’s sake, as bringing to mind all the promises made to Abraham), of the tribe of Benjamin (so Philippians 3:5). There is some question with what intent the Apostle here brings forward himself. Three ways are open to us: either (1) it is as a case in point, as an example of an Israelite who has not been rejected but is still one of God’s people: so almost all the Commentators—but this is hardly probable,—for in this case ( á ) he would not surely bring one only example to prove his point, when thousands might have been alleged—( â ) it would be hardly consistent with the humble mind of Paul to put himself alone in such a place,—and ( ã ) μὴγένοιτο does not go simply to deny a hypothetical fact, but applies to some deprecated consequence of that which is hypothetically put:—or (2) as De Wette, al., he implies, ‘How can I say such a thing, who am myself an Israelite, &c.?’ ‘Does not my very nationality furnish a security against my entertaining such an idea?’—or (3) which I believe to be the right view, but which I have found only in the commentary of Mr.
Ewbank,—as implying that if such a hypothesis were to be conceded, it would exclude from God’s kingdom the writer himself, as an Israelite. This seems better to agree with μὴγένοιτο, as deprecating the consequence of such an assertion.
But a question even more important arises, not unconnected with that just discussed: viz. who are ὁλαὸςαὐτοῦ? In order for the sentence καὶγὰρἐγὼκ. ô. ë. to bear the meaning just assigned to it, it is obvious that ὁλαὸςαὐτ. must mean the people of God nationally considered. If Paul deprecated such a proposition as the rejection of God’s people, because he himself would thus be as an Israelite cut off from God’s favour, the rejection assumed in the hypothesis must be a national rejection. It is against this that he puts in his strong protest. It is this which he disproves by a cogent historical parallel from Scripture, shewing that there is a remnant καὶἐντῷνῦνκαιρῷ according to the election of grace: and not only so, but that that part of Israel (considered as having continuity of national existence) which is for a time hardened, shall ultimately come in, and so all Israel (nationally considered again, Israel as a nation) shall be saved. Thus the covenant of God with Israel, having been national, shall ultimately be fulfilled to them as a nation: not by the gathering in merely of individual Jews, or of all the Jews individually, into the Christian church,—but by the national restoration of the Jews, not in unbelief, but as a Christian believing nation, to all that can, under the gospel, represent their ancient pre-eminence, and to the fulness of those promises which have never yet in their plain sense been accomplished to them.
I have entered on this matter here, because a clear understanding of it underlies all intelligent appreciation of the argument of the chapter. Those who hold no national restoration of the Jews to pre-eminence, must necessarily confound the ἐντῷνῦνκαιρῷ remnant according to the election of grace, with the οἱλοιποί, who nationally shall be grafted in again. See this more fully illustrated where that image occurs, Romans 11:17 ff.