What, then, dost thou say concerning Easter on the 21st or 22nd day of the moon, which (with thy peace be it said) is
proved by many calculators not to be Easter, but in truth a time of
darkness? For it is not unknown, as I believe, to thy Efficiency,
how Anatolius Anatolius, an Alexandrian by birth and bishop of Laodicea, a.d. 269, is referred to by Eusebius (H. E. VII.
32) as distinguished for learning, and the writer of a work on the
Paschal question, which he quotes. A “Canon
Paschalis,” purporting to be this work, was published by
Bucherius in a Latin Version (Doct. Temp. Antv. 1634); but its
genuineness is doubted. Anatolius was adduced by Colman at the
Synod of Whitby (Bede, H. E. III. 25), as an authority for the
14th and 20th days of the moon being the limits for Easter. But
Wilfrid replied that Anatolius had been misunderstood; for that, having
in view the Egyptian mode of reckoning days from sunset to sunset, he
had meant the day which began after sunset on the 14th day, i.e. really
the 15th. And so also with regard to the 20th day. His
language, as quoted by Eusebius, supports this explanation of his
meaning:—“Given that the day of the Passover is on the
fourteenth of the moon after evening (μεθ᾽
ἑσπέραν).” See
above, end of note 1. (a man of wonderful
learning, as says Saint Hieronymus, extracts from whose writings
Eusebius, bishop of Cæsarea, inserted in his Ecclesiastical
History, and Saint Hieronymus praised this same work about Easter in
his catalogue) disputes with strong disapprobation about this age of
the moon. For against the Gallican Rimarii “Forte sic dictos,
quod obscura et difficilia rimarentur.”
Benedictine edit. Migne.—“Nostri
rimeurs vocant poetastras, sed an ea sit hic notio non
definio.” Du Cange., who erred, as he says, about Easter, he
introduced an awful sentence, saying, Certainly, if the rising of
the moon be delayed till the end of two watches, which indicates
midnight, light does not overcome darkness, but darkness light; which
thing is certainly not allowable in the Easter Festival, namely, that
any part of the darkness should dominate over the light, since the
solemnity of the Lord’s Resurrection is light, and there is no
communion of light with darkness. And, if the moon has not shone
forth till the third watch, there is no doubt that the moon has risen
on its 21st or 22nd day, in which it is not possible for a true Paschal
offering to be made. For those who lay down that it is possible
for a true Easter to be celebrated at this age of the moon, not only
are unable to affirm this by authority of divine Scripture, but also
incur the guilt of sacrilege and contumacy and peril of their souls,
while affirming that the true Light, which dominates over all darkness,
can be offered while there is any domination of darkness. Also in
the book of holy dogma we read, Easter, that is, the solemnity of the
Lord’s Resurrection, cannot be celebrated before the beginning of
the vernal equinox is past, to wit, that it may not come before the
vernal equinox The original here, being
probably an incorrect citation, is obscure. It is “Pascha,
ed est solemnitas dominicæ Resurrectionis, ante transgressum
vernalis æquinoctii 16 initiam non potest celebrari, ut scilicet
æquinoctium non antecedat.”: which rule
assuredly Victorius Pope Leo I. referred the question between the Roman and Alexandrian Churches as to
the computation of Easter to his archdeacon (afterwards pope) Hilarius
for investigation; and he referred it to Victorius of Aquitaine, who
consequently (a.d. 457) drew up a cycle, which
was accepted first in the Gallican Churches (Concil. Aurel. IV.,
an. 541), and continued to be observed there after it had been
superseded in Italy by that of Dionysius Exiguus (a.d. 527). See above, note 1. has
gone beyond in his cycle, and hereby has already introduced error into
Gaul, or to speak less boldly, has confirmed one of old standing.
For indeed how can either of these things stand with reason; either
that the Lord’s Resurrection should be celebrated before His
Passion (the thought of which is absurd), or that the seven days
sanctioned by the Lord’s command in the Law, during which only it
is enjoined that the Lord’s Passover could lawfully be eaten
(which are to be numbered from the 14th day of the moon to the 20th),
should against law and right be exceeded? For a moon in its 21st
or 22nd day is out of the dominion of light, as having risen at that
time after midnight; and, when darkness overcomes light, it is said to
be impious to keep the solemnity of light. Why then dost thou,
who art so wise, the brilliant lights indeed of whose sacred genius are
diffused, as in ancient times, through the world,—why dost thou
keep a dark Easter? I wonder, I confess, that this error of Gaul,
ac si Schynteneum
“Schynteneum Græcam vocem σχοινοτενής
putat Editor, id est, tanquam si rectum et legitimum
esset.” Du Cange. This interpretation appears
probable from the fact that the Irish writers of the period were given
to air their Greek learning by the rise of such words.—“He
(Adamnan) occasionally employs Greek or Græco-Latin words”
(Reeves’s Adamnan. p. lxi. See also p. 158, note,
for other evidence of this Irish tendency). The meaning in the
text would thus be, “I wonder that this error should be tolerated
by thee as though it were right and legitimate.”, has not long ago
been swept away by thee; unless I should perchance suppose, what I can
hardly believe, that, as it is evident that thou hast not corrected it,
it has thy approval.