On the other hand, very many of Origen’s
pupils, especially among the bishops, started from the other side of
Origen’s teaching, and held tenaciously to the coeternity of the
Son, while they abandoned the Origenist ‘paradoxes’ with
regard to the Universe, matter, pre-existence, and restitution. Typical
of this class is Gregory Thaumaturgus, also Peter the martyr bishop of
Alexandria, who expressly opposed many of Origen’s positions
(though hardly with the violence ascribed to him in certain supposed
fragments in Routh, Rell. iv. 81) and Alexander himself. It was
this ‘wing’ of the Origenist following that, in combination
with the opposition represented by Methodius, bequeathed to the
generation contemporary with Nicæa its average theological tone.
The coeternity of the Son with the Father was not (as a rule)
questioned, but the essential relation of the Logos to the Creation
involved a strong subordination of the Son to the Father, and by
consequence of the Spirit to the Son. Monarchianism was the heresy most
dreaded, the theology of the Church was based on the philosophical
categories of Plato applied to the explanation and systematisation of
the rule of faith. This was very far from Arianism. It lacked the
logical definiteness of that system on the one hand, it rested on the
other hand on a different conception of God; the hypostatic
subordination of the Son was insisted upon, but His true Sonship as of
one Nature with the Father, was held fast. In the slow process of time
this neo-Asiatic theology found its way partly to the Nicene formula,
partly to the illogical acceptance of it with regard to the Son, with
refusal to apply it to the Spirit (Macedonius). To the men who thought
thus, the blunt assertion that the Son was a creature, not coeternal,
alien to the Essence of the Father, was a novelty, and wholly
abhorrent. Arius drew a sharper line than they had been accustomed to
draw between God and the creature; so did Athanasius. But Arius drew
his line without flinching between the Father and the Son. This to the
instinct of any Origenist was as revolting as it would have been to the
clear mind and Biblical sympathy of Origen himself. In theological and
philosophical principles alike Arius was opposed even to the tempered
Origenism of the Nicene age. The latter was at the furthest remove from
Monarchianism, Arianism was in its essential core Monarchian;
the common theology borrowed its philosophical principles and method
from the Platonists, Arius from Aristotle. To anticipate, Arianism and
(so-called) semi-Arianism have in reality very little in common except
the historical fact of common action for a time. Arianism guarded the
transcendence of the divine nature (at the expense of revelation and
redemption) in a way that ‘semi-Arianism,’ admitting as it
did inherent inequality in the Godhead, did not. They therefore tended
in opposite directions; Arianism to Anomœanism,
‘semi-Arianism’ to the Nicene faith; their source was
different. ‘Aristotle made men Arians,’ says Newman with
truth, ‘Plato, semi-Arians’ (Arians4, p.
335, note): but to say this is to allow that if Arianism goes back to
Lucian and so to Paul of Samosata, semi-Arianism is a fragment from the
wreck of Origen.