The controversy arose in the following way. During
the struggle with Pelagianism between the years 410 and 420,
Augustine’s views on the absolute need of grace were gradually
hardening into a theory that grace was irresistible and therefore
indefectible. “Intent above all things on magnifying the Divine
Sovereignty, he practically forgot the complexity of the problem in
hand and failed to do justice to the human element in the mysterious
process of man’s salvation.” The Anti-Pelagian
Treatises of S. Augustine; with an Introduction by William Bright,
D.D. (Oxford), 1889, p. 1. The
view of an absolute predestination irrespective of foreseen character,
and of the irresistible and indefectible character of grace, was put
forward by him, in a letter to a Roman priest, Sixtus, in the year
418. Epistle xciv. Some years afterwards this letter fell
into the hands of the monks of Adrumetum, some of whom were puzzled by
its teaching; and, in order to allay the disputes among them, the
matter was referred to Augustine himself. Thinking that the monks had
misunderstood his teaching, he not only explained the letter but also
wrote a fresh treatise,—“De Gratia et Libero
Arbitrio” (426); and, when that failed
to satisfy the malcontents, he followed
it up with his work “De Correptione et Gratia” (426),
which, so far as the monks of Adrumetum were concerned, seems to have
ended the controversy. Elsewhere, however, hesitation was felt in going
the full length of Augustine’s teaching; and, in the South of
Gaul especially, many were seriously disturbed at the turn which the
controversy had lately taken, and were prepared to reject
Augustine’s teaching, as not merely novel, but also practically
dangerous. “They said, in effect,” to quote Canon
Bright’s lucid summary of their position, “to treat
predestination as irrespective of foreseen conduct, and to limit the
Divine good-will to a fixed number of persons thus selected, who, as
such, are assured of perseverance, is not only to depart from the older
theology, and from the earlier teaching of the Bishop of Hippo himself,
but to cut at the root of religious effort, and to encourage either
negligence or despair. They insisted that whatever theories might be
devised concerning this mystery, which was not a fit subject for
popular discussion, the door of salvation should be regarded as open to
all, because the Saviour ‘died for all.’ To explain away
the Scriptural assurance was, they maintained, to falsify the Divine
promise and to nullify human responsibility. They believed in the
doctrine of the Fall; they acknowledged the necessity of real grace in
order to man’s restoration; they even admitted that this grace
must be ‘prevenient’ to such acts of will as resulted in
Christian good works: but some of them thought—and herein
consisted the error called Semi-Pelagian—that nature, unaided,
could take the first step towards its recovery, by desiring to be
healed through faith in Christ. If it could not,—if the very
beginning of all good were strictly a Divine act,—exhortations
seemed to them to be idle, and censure unjust, in regard to those on
whom no such act had been wrought, and who, therefore, until it should
be wrought, were helpless, and so far guiltless, in the
matter.” Anti-Pelagian
Treatises, p. liv., lv. Of the party which
took up this position Cassian was the recognized head. True, he did not
directly enter into the controversy himself, nor is he the author of
any polemical works upon the subject; but it is impossible to doubt
that the thirteenth Conference, containing the teaching of Abbot
Chæremon on the Protection of God, was intended to meet what he
evidently regarded as a serious error; viz., the implicit denial by the
Augustinians of the need of effort on man’s
part.