For the dates of the first group of Roman bishops, from Peter to
Urbanus, the best source we have is Eusebius’Church
History; but for the second group, from Pontianus to Liberius, the
notices of the History are very unreliable, while the Liberian
catalogue rests upon very trustworthy data (see Lipsius, Chron. d.
röm. Bischöfe, p. 39 and p. 142 sq.). We must therefore
turn to the latter for the most accurate information in regard to the
remaining Roman bishops mentioned by Eusebius, although an occasional
mistake in the catalogue must be corrected by our other sources, as
Lipsius points out. The notice of Eusebius at this point would throw
the accession of Pontianus into the year 231, but this is a year too
late, as seen in chap. 21, note 4. According to chap. 29, he was bishop
six years, and was succeeded by Anteros at about the same time that
Gordian became emperor; that is, in 238. But this is wide of the truth.
The Liberian catalogue, which is supported by the best of the other
sources, gives a little over five years for his episcopate, and puts
his banishment to Sardinia, with which his episcopate ended, on the
28th of September, 235. According to the Felician catalogue, which may
be trusted at this point, he was brought to Rome and buried there
during the episcopate of Fabian, which began in 236 (see also the
preceding chapter, note 1). We know nothing about the life and
character of Pontianus.