Cburcb flbusic. iudited By B. Himtincton Woo^tman.
THE POSTLIIDE.
Dr. Henry G. Hanchett.
Tke proposal has been seriously made before
a body of profeesional musicians, by an organ¬
ist of high standing, that the postlude be
abandoned. This is certainly a rather start¬
ling suggestion, and one not to be accepted
too hastily. It reminds the writer of an even
more radical, almost revolutionary proposition
made in apparent seriousness a few years ago
by an English religious journal of large cir¬
culation and influence; nothing less, namely,
than the abandonment of the prayer-meeting
in view of the long continued and oft-repeated
complaints of its dullness and unprofltable-
ness. The latter suggestion as might have
been expected, aroused widespread opposi¬
tion. Hardly a religious paper could be found
to second it or to give it any support, and it
really seemed for a time as if some new life
and power might be infused into the weekly
conference meeting as a result of this implied
attack upon it and the discussion thereby
occasioned.
Possibly some similar result might be
brought about by an analogous course regard¬
ing the postlude. I doubt if many organists
could be found who would really be willing
to abandon the postlude of their own accord,
but might it not be worth while to suggest
such a course to the church, or to a particu¬
lar congregation, in the hope of starting a
discussion and thus reviving (if that word can
be properly used in this connection) interest
in this widely used element of the order of
worship? If the organist has any realizing
sense of the resources of the instrument placed
at his disposal, and the ability to display them
worthily and unto edification, he looks upon
the postlude as his opportunity. The time
was, in our Protestant churches, when organ
solos were not unusual at the oflfertory, but
in recent years custom has come to demand
a vocal selection at that time. Of course no
well informed organist expects the prelude to
receive any attention; even that small propor¬
tion of the congregation that are in their seats
during its entire length are disturbed by the
late comers. And so it has come to pass that
the only opportunity left the organist at
which he can hope to create an impression,
whether for good or evil, upon the minds of
the assembled congregation is at the postlude ;
need it be said that he who counts much on
this opportunity is likely to become somewhat
disheartened?
Why, then, would it not be wise to prepare
one or two service lists, omitting the postlude?
It is not too much to hope that possibly some
attention might thus be drawn to the office
The hint might be taken that since the organ¬
ist has been asked to play, he is entitled to
some attention; that since the feature has
been made a part of the service, it may have
some value discoverable through its accept¬
ance.
Another way of restoring (dare I say?) the
postlude to its legitimate place might possibly
be found in the suggestion to the minister
that it is*a recognized part of the order of
worship, asking him to set the example by
resuming bis seat and listening reverently
till its conclusion. Such a course on the part
of the clergyman, if taken without explana¬
tion, may lead those to obj^’ct who count upon
a social word*at the close of the sermon I
have known one music-loving pastor who
always resumes bis seat and listens reverently
THE EVANGELIST.
and with evident enjoyment to the entire
postlude—a custom which his example has led
many in bis church to observe to their un¬
doubted profit—to be interrupted and called
down from the pulpit by unthinking friends
from other congregations not quick enough to
perceive the significance of his rather unusual
behavior; but such interruptions only serve
to show how general is the convic ion that
the postlude is simply a more agreeable kind
of noise introduced to cover the less agreeable
sort produced by the tread of feet and the
buzz of low voiced conversation.
If the postlude is worth playing, it is worth
hearing. If the organist’s effort for the up
building of music is valued by the church, it
can find few better ways of letting him know
it than by giving attention to what is often
one of the most costly and valuable of his
contributions to the service of the day. Un¬
less the people are willing to grant so much,
what objection have they to urge against the
suppression of the postlude?
HYMNS OR TUNES?
New York, July 24, 1896.
To THE Musical Editor or The Evangelist
Dear Sir:—Your recent remark is just, that
the people, as a rule, sing the tunes rather
than the hymns. The melody carries them
along, rests them, gratifies them, and the senti¬
ment of the hymn is often of minor impor¬
tance, not to say, of no importance. Haven’t
you heard a company of Christian people in
a prayer-meeting sing lustily, “We’re on our
way to heaven above; will you go? will you
go?” repeating the question twenty or thirty
times? What is the philosophy of it? Are
they appealing to the unconverted to join
them? By no means; there may not be one
of them within a mile.
Or, to lake another case, why do people sing
with such gusto their favorite “.Sweet hour of
prayer,” and announce with so great satisfac
tion their purpose, when their souls take flight
to a better world, to
“ Shout, while parsing through the ai'.
Farewell, farewell, sweet hour of prayer!" ?
Is it anything but the tune that carries them
through such an utterance as that?
Alas, tee do not sing devoutly. Too many of
our hymns are not at all hymns of worship.
They do not lift our hearts toward God.
■’Fwas always so within my remembrance.
The minister would be looking over his ser¬
mon when he had set the people to singing
The sexton would be adjusting the window
shades, the mess<>nger would be bearing notes
to the pulpit, the deacons would be “lifting
a collection” during the singing. The “per
formance” of an anthem, even though it con
tained the words, “O Lamb of God, that
takest away the sins of the world, have mercy
upon us,” would give opportunity for bodily
relaxation. We don’t (that is, we don’t
always) mean what we say when we sing.
Who would allow a passing of theplites while
the minister was praying? Do not many
things tend to show that, as a rule we sing
the tunes and care but little for the words
which are behind them? E W. O.
ORGANIST aud Choir-master, 15 years’ practical ex¬
perience. at present actively engagtd in three im-
p.,rtant Philadelnbla churches, is desirous of making a
cbHDge tiept. 1st; hold.s highest testimonials regarding
ability and character. Address "c,” P. O. Box 592,
Philadelpbia, lor one month.
FARRAND & VOTEY,
HIGH GRADE ORGANS. Correspondence Solicited. DETROIT, MICH.
CHURCH ORGAN FOR SALE. Our Make. Cost $2400. Price, $1200,
Hook & Hastings Co., Boston.
July 30, 18»6.
810.000 IN PRIZES
OFFERED TO
AMERICAN CHOIRS
R. Marriner Floyd, the President of the re-organ¬
ized Boston Conservatory of Music, offers a schedule
of prizes, aggregating 110,000 in value, to American
Choirs, under conditions
® which will be found pro-
motive of the best interests
of worship-music in this
The Boston Conserva¬
tory (founded by Julius
Eichberg in 1867) has al¬
ways stood for thorough
and true musicianship,
and this unparalleled offer
R. MARUIXER FLOYD. .. , Will still further identify
the Conservatory with the best musical culture.
Over Fifty Choirs have already entered for these
prizes. For particulars, address
Mr. R. MARRINER FLOYD,
Boston Conservatory of Music,
154 Tremont St., Boston, Mass,.
The Church Music Department
OF THE
Metropolitan College of Music
OFFERS A COURSE IN CHOIR TRAINI.NG,
AND THE
SELECTION AND RENDITION OF CHURCH MUSIC.
BEOINNINO IN SEPTEMBER.
Programs and dates will be sent on application.
JOHN CORNELIUS GRIGGS,
21 East 14th St., New York City.
SEND FOR CO.MPLETE OATA1.00UE OF COLLEGE WORK.
GOSPEL HYMNS, I to 6. Excel. Mns KiT , Ha iier KKI; Words Ed., #10 upwards per 100.
Christian Endeavor Hymns. #<0 |>e 100.
THH IU«IA>W A MAIN CO.
76 East !Uh St., New York, 215 Wabash Avc , Chleago,.
\^arren H-Hayes
/yc,HiTECT«
^INItWPOUS^^^^^
PLANS 3
Wofk Correct
and f^odern
Acoustics and
Ventilation
Guaranteed.
References from A
."wenty-tive yearr
' Practice.
Orders and con¬
sultation by mait
given carnful at¬
tention.
MENEELY BELL COMPANY,
Clinton H. MIeneely, Cent Manaeer
TffOF. N. r ,nnd VFH CITV,
MANUFACTURE SUPERIOR SELLS.
.dSL. VniillXOTESBBZLU
TIVITBtf iO^SFtETlI, UOU SUl-
^Ullor^U LOWZS FEICE. rnuKvFn
^_** TILLSWH7.
rite to Cincinnati Bell Foundry Co., Cincinnati, a
A RFII MAm Ml School, for Firs,
BELL FOUNDRY CO., Northvillb, Mich
PRE8EBVE YOUB EYANOEI.IST8.
Mow that The Evangelist is pablisbed in a shape con¬
venient for binding, many of Ite readers will wien a
ilnder for the purpose of keeping a file In the best order
We can supply snch a binder for 25 oents each, postage
prepaid. Address The RviNOELisr, P. O, Box 2886, Ne
Fork pttv
XUM