Now we know that there were at least two towns of the name of Carcha: for the anonymous
Ravenna geographer1441 tells us that there was a place of that name in Arabia Felix; and
Ammianus Marcellinus1442 mentions another beyond the Tigris, within the Persian
dominion. The clear statements, however, to the effect that the locality of the bishopric of
Archelaus was in Mesopotamia, make it impossible that either of these two towns could
have been the seat of his rule. Besides this, in the third chapter of the Acts themselves we
find the name Charra occurring; and hence Zacagnius and others have concluded that the
place actually intended is the scriptural Charran, or Haran, in Mesopotamia, which is also
written Charra in Paulus Diaconus,1443 and that the form Carchar or Carchara was either
a mere error of the transcribers, or the vulgar provincial designation. It must be added,
however, that Neander1444 allows this to be only a very uncertain conjecture, while others
hold that Caschar is the most probable scription, and that the town is one altogether different
from the ancient Haran.
The date of the Disputation itself admits of tolerably exact settlement. Epiphanius, in-
deed,1445 says that Manes fled into Mesopotamia in the ninth year of the reign of Valerianus
and Gallienus, and that the discussion with Archelaus took place about the same time. This
would carry the date back to about 262 a.d. But this statement, although he is followed in
it by Petrus Siculus and Photius, is inconsistent with the specification of times which he
makes in dealing with the error of the Manichæans in his book On the Heresies. From the
37th chapter of the Acts, however, we find that the Disputation took place, not when Gal-
177
lienus, but when Probus held the empire, and that is confirmed by Cyril of Jerusalem.1446
The exact year becomes also clearer from Eusebius, who1447 seems to indicate the second
year of the reign of Probus as the time when the Manichæan heresy attained general publi-
city—Secundo anno Probi…insana Manichæorum hæresis in commune humani generis
malum exorta; and from Leo Magnus, who in his second Discourse on Pentecost also avers
that Manichæus became notorious in the consulship of Probus and Paulinus. And as this
consulship embraced part of the first and part of the second years of the empire of Probus,
the Disputation itself would thus be fixed as occurring in the end of a.d. 277 or the beginning
of 278, or, according to the precise calculation of Zacagnius, between July and December
of the year 277.
1441 Geogr., book. ii. ch. 7.
1442 Book xviii. 23, and xxv. 20, 21.
1443 Hist. Misc., xxii. 20.
1444 Church History, ii. p. 165, ed. Bohn.
1445 De Mensur. et Pond., ch. 20.
1446 Cateches., vi. p. 140.
1447 Chronicon, lib. post., p. 177.
414
Introductory Notice.