“Thus do the private animosities of the clergy
from time to time greatly injure the Church and divide religion into
many heresies! And this is a proof; for had George, like Theodotus,
received Apolinarius, on his repentance, into communion, I believe that
we should never have heard of the heresy that bears his name. Men are
prone, when loaded with opprobrium and contempt, to resort to rivalries
and innovations; whereas, when treated with justice, they become
moderate and remain in the same position.” More emphatic still is
his protest in vi. 26: “Those varying dogmas are the source of
innumerable troubles to religion, and many are deterred from embracing
Christianity by the diversity of opinion which prevails in matters of
doctrine.” In the beginning of this same chapter, in speaking of
the Eunomians, he delineates them thus: “They do not applaud a
good course of life or manner of conduct, or mercy towards the needy,
unless exhibited by persons of their own sect, so much as skill in
disputation and the power of triumphing in debates.” This is a
great blow at the sectores cymini, and at pride in polemics; the
whole tone is much more liberal than that of the ecclesiastic
Theodoret, or even the lawyer Evagrius. Sozomen, like Socrates,
represents a generous feeling current among the laymen of
Constantinople in court and among the trades and professions. The
attitude of the Catholic Church with regard to baptism he sets forth
adequately as trivial, and argues against the Eunomian innovation of
one baptism and a change in the formula (vi. 21): “But whether it
was Eunomius or any other person who first made these innovations upon
the tradition of baptism, it seems to me that such innovators, whoever
they may have been, were alone in danger, according to their own
representation, of quitting this life without having received Divine
baptism.” The argument here is an unusually long one; with his
generation he held to the magical efficacy of the rite. The theory of
the sacraments as mysteries or arcane, was one which controlled him
throughout, and even limited his fidelity as a historian. Thus in i.
20: “I thought it necessary to reproduce the very document (the
Nicene Creed) concerning these matters, as an example of the truth, in
order that posterity might possess in a fixed and clear form, the
symbol of that faith which proved pacifying at the time; but since some
pious friends who understood such matters, recommended that these
truths ought to be spoken of and heard by the initiated and their
initiators only, I agreed with their counsel: for it is not unlikely
that some of the uninitiated may read this book: while I have concealed
such of the prohibited material as I ought to keep silent about, I have
not altogether left the reader ignorant of the opinions held by the
Synod.” Nor will he repeat the symbol as subjoined to the letter
of the council of Antioch (vi. 4); and when the Macedonian commission
to Liberius make their statement, and the text is given to show their
entire acceptance of the Nicene view, Sozomen will not reproduce it.
Again in vi. 29, Mark was a monk of “such eminent piety, that
Macarius himself, the presbyter of Celliæ, declared that he had
never given to him what priests present to the initiated at the holy
table; but that an angel, administering it to him, whose hand up to the
forearm, he declared himself to have seen.” In viii. 5, in giving
the account of a marvelous judgment wrought on a Macedonian wife, who
pretended to be a convert to the Nicene views, and thus frequented the
orthodox ceremony of the Supper, he remarks, “At the time of the
celebration of the mysteries (the initiated will understand what I
mean), this woman kept what was given her, and held down her head as if
engaged in prayer.” In reciting the disturbances at the Easter
celebration over the decree of exile against Chrysostom (viii. 21), he
says: “They were charged with
the commission of such disorderly acts as can be readily conceived by
those who have been admitted to the mysteries, but which I consider it
requisite to pass over in silence, lest my work should fall into the
hands of the uninitiated.” Here we have a glimpse of the scope of
the arcane as well as the weakness of the historian in submitting to
the advice of narrow friends; no other historian felt bound to restrict
himself in such matters. Sozomen here joined the most extreme
sacramentarians of his day. On the weighty matter of discipline, he
believes with the Catholic Church in receiving back the penitent into
the Church, against Novatian and Donatistic practices. He expresses his
opinion at some length, though not so fully as Socrates, in the chapter
which relates to the abolition of the penitential presbyter (vii. 16):
“Impeccability is a Divine attribute, and belongs not to human
nature; therefore God has decreed that pardon should be extended to the
penitent even after many transgressions. As in supplicating for pardon,
it is requisite to confess the sin, it seems probable that the priests,
from the beginning, considered it irksome to make this confession in
public, before the whole assembly of the people. They appointed a
presbyter of the utmost sanctity and the most undoubted prudence, to
act on those occasions: the penitents went to him and confessed their
transgressions; and it was his office to indicate the kind of penance
adapted to each sin, and then when satisfaction had been made, to
pronounce absolution.” He deplores the abolition of the office as
the occasion of laxity. The deterrent force of public confession was
now lost, and that to the danger of Christian conduct. He sympathizes
also with that form of martyrdom which wantonly and ruthlessly assails
paganism and is slain in the attempt. The system of relic-worship, so
characteristic of any decline of opportunity for heroic action, had set
in overwhelmingly, and he believed in it vigorously. Our own age
reproduces the same tendency not only in religious, but in secular
forms, and among Protestants as well. Thus he commemorates: of Old
Testament prophets, Micah and Habakkuk (vii. 29), Zechariah (ix. 17);
of the preparatory period, the head of John the Baptist (vii. 21); of
the Apostolic Church, St. Stephen (vii. 29, ix. 16); of the martyrs,
Babylas (v. 19), Forty Soldiers (ix. 2); of the monks, Hilarion (iii.
14), the four brothers (vii. 9). The most prominent of secondary relics
is the cross with its inscriptions and nails (ii. 1). The discovery of
these is mainly through prayer and heavenly signs; their possession is
an object of imperial ambition; the removal and transportation of them
are effected with most gorgeous and reverent pomp; and the sacred
treasures become the agents of endless miracles.