whether by one interchange of letters or by many. He pleads that present interests alone
may be touched upon. Schism according to the Old Testament was more severely punished
than idolatry or the burning of the sacred scroll. The charge of traditorship is set off by the
acceptance of the Maximianists, whom the council of Bagai had condemned in such severe
terms. If a mistake was made with regard to them why not in Cæcilian’s case? If these were
really guilty, you consulted the wider duties of unity and toleration, and why not carry these
principles farther and apply them to communion with the Catholics? As to the charge of
persecution, Augustin will not enter into the merits of the matter theoretically, nor stop to
plead the mildness of the measures used, but at once asks why the Donatists used the State
379
to dislodge the Maximianists, and to deny the Catholics the possession of genuine baptism
is made foolish by the recognition of the rite as existing among the Maximianists who had
been cut off, and were restored without a renewal of the ceremony. The whole world had
been condemned by the Donatists without an opportunity of being heard, and yet they accept
the sacrament of the condemned Felicianus and Prætextatus. While they deny the validity
of the symbol as administered by apostolic communions, and by the missionary churches
which brought the light to Africa, they maintain that their little fraction alone is its possessor.
Summarizing these arguments as a weight for the bishop to stagger under, he invokes the
peace of Christ to conquer his heart.
In this same year one of his relatives, Severinus, who was a Donatist, sent a communic-
ation to him at Hippo by a special messenger, with a view of reopening friendly intercourse
with his kinsman; and Augustin seizes it as a way to reestablish as well the higher kinship
in Christ (Ep. lii.). The Church is an unconcealable city set on a hill; it is Catholic, being
diffused throughout the whole world. The party of Donatus is cut off from the historic root
of the Oriental churches, and therefore cannot bring forth the fruits of peace and love; indeed
it suppresses Christ by its rebaptism. Had their charges been genuine the transmarine
bishops would have supported them; at any rate they should not have withdrawn from the
Unity, but rather have practiced toleration. He hopes that the bonds of custom may be
broken by Severinus, and that both may find their truest relationship in Christ, since the
state of schism is a despising of the eternal heritage and of perpetual salvation.
Further along in the year, a Donatist presbyter had sent to Generosus an ordo Christi-
anitatis, or episcopal succession of Constantina, his native city, asserting that it had been
delivered by an angel from heaven. About nothing were the church externalists of every
camp so eager as the preservation of the succession in proof of antiquity. Generosus had
only laughed at the man’s stupidity, but nevertheless wrote to the bishop of Hippo about
it. Fortunatus, Alypius and Augustin combine in a reply, undeniably written by the latter,
commending him (Ep. liii.). The ordo Christianitatis of the whole world is theirs, from
which the Donatists do not hesitate to separate themselves. This presbyter’s fiction would
have to be rejected at any rate, even had it come from an angel, since all other gospels than
656
An Analysis of Augustin’s Writings Against the Donatists.