Therefore, not even supposing, as our argument did for a moment, that an advantage were
allowed on the score of time, can they properly ascribe to the Father alone the highest su-
premacy of being: but as there is really no difference whatever in the prerogative of time,
how could any one possibly entertain such an idea about these existencies which are pre-
temporal? Every measure of distance that we could discover is beneath the divine nature:
so no ground is left for those who attempt to divide this pre-temporal and incomprehensible
being by distinctions of superior and inferior.
We have no hesitation either in asserting that what is dogmatically taught by them is
an advocacy of the Jewish doctrine, setting forth, as they do, that the being of the Father
alone has subsistence, and insisting that this only has proper existence, and reckoning that
of the Son and the Spirit among non-existencies, seeing that what does not properly exist
can be said nominally only, and by an abuse of terms, to exist at all. The name of man, for
instance, is not given to a portrait representing one, but to so and so who is absolutely such,
the original of the picture, and not the picture itself; whereas the picture is in word only a
man, and does not possess absolutely the quality ascribed to it, because it is not in its nature
that which it is called. In the case before us, too, if being is properly ascribed to the Father,
but ceases when we come to the Son and the Spirit, it is nothing short of a plain denial of
the message of salvation. Let them leave the church and fall back upon the synagogues of
the Jews, proving, as they do, the Son’s non-existence in denying to Him proper being. What
does not properly exist is the same thing as the non-existent.
Again, he means in all this to be very clever, and has a poor opinion of those who essay
to write without logical force. Then let him tell us, contemptible though we are, by what
sort of skill he has detected a greater and a less in pure being. What is his method for estab-
lishing that one being is more of a being than another being,—taking being in its plainest
meaning, for he must not bring forward those various qualities and properties, which are
comprehended in the conception of the being, and gather round it, but are not the subject
itself? Shade, colour, weight, force or reputation, distinctive manner, disposition, any quality
thought of in connection with body or mind, are not to be considered here: we have to inquire
only whether the actual subject of all these, which is termed absolutely the being, differs in
degree of being from another. We have yet to learn that of two known existencies, which
still exist, the one is more, the other less, an existence. Both are equally such, as long as they
are in the category of existence, and when all notions of more or less value, more or less
force, have been excluded.
If, then, he denies that we can regard the Only-begotten as completely existing,—for to
this depth his statement seems to lead,—in withholding from Him a proper existence, let
him deny it even in a less degree. If, however, he does grant that the Son subsists in some
substantial way—we will not quarrel now about the particular way—why does he take away
again that which he has conceded Him to be, and prove Him to exist not properly, which
99
He does wrong in making the being of the Father alone proper and supreme,…