SECT. VII.
What is, and what is not, begging the question; and how Mr. W. charges me, from time
to time, with begging the question, without cause.
Among the particulars of Mr. W.‘s method of disputing, I observed, that he often
causelessly charges me with begging the question, while he frequently begs the question himself,
or does that which is equivalent.
But that it may be determined with justice and clearness, who does, and who does not,
beg the question, I desire it may be particularly considered, what that is which is called
begging the question in a dispute.—This is more especially needful for the sake of illiterate
readers. And here,
1. Let it be observed, that merely to suppose something in a dispute, without bringing
any argument to prove it, is not begging the question: for this is done necessarily, in every
dispute, and even in the best and clearest demonstrations. One point is proved by another,
till at length the matter is reduced to a point that is supposed to need no proof; either because
it is self-evident, or is a thing wherein both parties are agreed, or so clear that it is supposed
it will not be denied.
2. Nor is begging the question the same thing as offering a weak argument, to prove the
point in question. It is not all weak arguing, but one particular way of weak arguing, that is
called begging the question.
3. Nor is it the same thing as missing the true question, and bringing an argument that
is impertinent, or beside the question.
But the thing which is called begging the question, is the making use of the very point
in debate, or the thing to be proved, as an argument to prove itself. Thus, if I were endeav-
ouring to prove that none but godly persons might come to sacraments, and should take
this for an argument to prove it, that none might come but such as have saving faith, taking
this for granted; I should then beg the question: for this is the very point in question,
whether a man must have saving faith or no? It is called begging the question, because it is
a depending as it were on the courtesy of the other side, to grant me the point in question,
without offering any argument as the price of it.
And whether the point I thus take for granted, be the main point in question, in the
general dispute, or some subordinate point, something under consideration, under a partic-
ular argument; yet if I take this particular point for granted, and then make use of it to prove
itself, it is begging the question.
Thus if I were endeavouring, under this general controversy between Mr. W. and me,
to prove that particular point, that we ought to love all the members of the church as true
saints; and should bring this as a proof of the point, that we ought to love all the members
of the church as true Christians, taking this for granted; this is only the same thing, under
SECTION VII. Begging the question.
1987
SECTION VII. Begging the question.