The responsibility of Cyril in this affair has been
variously estimated by different historians. Walch, Gibbon, and Milman
incline to hold him guilty. J. C. Robertson ascribes him indirect
responsibility, asserting that the perpetrators of the crime
‘were mostly officers of his church, and had unquestionably drawn
encouragement from his earlier proceedings.’ Hist. of the
Christ. Ch. Vol. I. p. 401. W. Bright says, ‘Cyril was no
party to this hideous deed, but it was the work of men whose passions
he had originally called out. Had there been no onslaught on the
synagogues, there would doubtless have been no murder of
Hypatia.’ Hist. of the Church from 313 to 451, pp.
274, 275. See also Schaff, Hist. of the Christ. Ch. Vol. III. p.
943.