The extreme age of Narcissus at this time is evident from the fact
that Alexander, writing before the year 216 (see note 4), says that
Narcissus is already in his 116th year. The translation of Alexander to
Jerusalem must have taken place about 212 (see chap. 8, note 6), and
hence Narcissus was now more than 110 years old. The appointment of
Alexander as Narcissus’ assistant involved two acts which were
even at that time not common, and which were later forbidden by canon;
first the translation of a bishop from one see to another, and secondly
the appointment of an assistant bishop, which made two bishops in one
city. The Apost. Canons (No. 14) ordain that “a bishop
ought not to leave his own parish and leap to another, although the
multitude should compel him, unless there be some good reason forcing
him to do this, as that he can contribute much greater profit to the
people of the new parish by the word of piety; but this is not to be
settled by himself, but by the judgment of many bishops and very great
supplication.” It has been disputed whether this canon is older
or younger than the fifteenth canon of Nicæa, which forbids
unconditionally the practice of translation from one see to another.
Whichever may be the older, it is certain that even the Council of
Nicæa considered its own canon as liable to exceptions in certain
cases, for it translated Eustathius from Beræa to Antioch (see
Sozomen, H. E. I. 2). The truth is, the rule was
established—whether before or for the first time at the Council
of Nicæa—chiefly in order to guard against the ambition of
aspiring men who might wish to go from a smaller to a greater parish,
and to prevent, as the Nicene Canon says, the many disorders and
quarrels which the custom of translation caused; and a rule formed on
such grounds of expediency was of course liable to exception whenever
the good of the Church seemed to demand it, and therefore, whether the
fourteenth Apostolic Canon is more ancient than the Nicene Council or
not, it certainly embodies a principle which must long have been in
force, and which we find in fact acted upon in the present case; for
the translation of Alexander takes place “with the common consent
of the bishops of the neighboring churches,” or, as Jerome puts
it, cunctis in Palestina episcopis in unum congregatis, which is
quite in accord with the provision of the Apostolic Canons. There were
some in the early Church who thought it absolutely unlawful under any
circumstances for a bishop to be translated (cf. Jerome’s Ep.
ad Oceanum; Migne, Ep. 69, §5), but this was not the
common view, as Bingham (Antiq. VI. 4. 6) well observes, and
instances of translation from one see to another were during all these
centuries common (cf. e.g. Socrates, H. E. VII. 36), although
always of course exceptional, and considered lawful only when made for
good and sufficient reasons. To say, therefore, with Valesius that
these Palestinian bishops violated a rule of the Church in translating
Alexander is too strong. They were evidently unconscious of anything
uncanonical, or even irregular in their action, though it is clear that
they regarded the step as too important to be taken without the
approval of all the bishops of the neighborhood. In regard to assistant
bishops, Valesius correctly remarks that this is the first instance of
the kind known to us, but it is by no means the only one, for the
following centuries furnish numerous examples; e.g. Theotecnus and
Anatolius in Cæsarea (see below, Bk. VII. chap. 32), Maximus and
Macarius in Jerusalem (see Sozomen, H. E. II. 20); and so in
Africa Valerius of Hippo had Augustine as his coadjutor (Possidius,
Vita. Aug. chap. 8; see Bingham’s Antiq. II. 13. 4
for other instances and for a discussion of the whole subject). The
principle was in force from as early as the third century (see Cyprian
to Cornelius, Ep. 40, al. 44 and to Antonianus,
Ep. 51, al. 55) that there should be only one bishop in a
city, and we see from the works of various Fathers that this rule was
universally accepted at an early date. The eighth canon of Nicæa
refers to this principle in passing as if it were already firmly
established, and the council evidently did not think it necessary to
promulgate a special canon on the subject. Because of this principle,
Augustine hesitated to allow himself to be ordained assistant bishop of
Hippo; and although his scruples were overcome at the time, he
afterward, upon learning of the Nicene Canon, considered the practice
of having a coadjutor illegal and refused to ordain one for himself.
But, as the instances referred to above and many others show, not all
the Church interpreted the principle as rigidly as Augustine did, and
hence under certain circumstances exceptions were made to the rule, and
were looked upon throughout the Church as quite lawful. The existence
of two bishops in one city as a matter of compromise, for the sake of
healing a schism, formed one common exception to the general principle
(see Bingham, II. 13. 2), and the appointment of coadjutors, as in the
present case, formed another.