cf.
Glubokowski. pp. 237, 239. Du Pin. iv. 83. Cardinal Newman, in his very
bright and sympathetic sketch of Theodoret, (Hist. Sketches ii. 308 ed.
1891) writes the following remarkable sentence. “This, at least,
he has in common with St. Chrysostom that both of them were deprived of
their episcopal rank by a council, both appealed to the holy see, and
by the holy see both were cleared and restored to their ecclesiastical
dignities.” It would be difficult in the compass of so short a
sentence to combine more statements so completely misleading. To say
that Chrysostom and Theodoret both appealed to the “holy
see” is as much an anachronism as to say that they appealed to
the Court of the Vatican or to the Dome of St. Peter’s. In their
day there was no holy see, that is to say, κατ᾽
ἐξοχήν. All
sees were holy sees, just as all bishops were styled your holiness.
Rome, it is true, was the only apostolical see in the West, but it was
not the only apostolical see, and whatever official precedence it could
claim over Antioch, Jerusalem, and Alexandria, was due to its being the
see of the old imperial capital, a precedence expressly ordered at
Chalcedon to be shared with the new Rome on the Bosphorus. As to the
“appeal,” we have seen what it meant in the case of
Theodoret. It meant the same in the case of Chrysostom. Cut to the
quick at the cruel and brutal treatment of his friends after his
banishment from Constantinople in the summer of 404 he pleaded his
cause in letters sent as well to Venerius of Milan and Chromatius of
Aquileia as to Innocent of Rome. Innocent very properly espoused his
cause, declared his deposition void, and did his best to move Honorius
to move Arcadius to convoke a council. The cruel story of the long
martyrdom of bitter exile and the death in the lonely chapel at Comana
is a terrible satire on the restoration to ecclesiastical dignities.
The unwary reader of “the historical sketch” might imagine
the famous John of the mouth of gold brought back in triumph to
Constantinople by the authority of the pope in 404 as he had been by
the enthusiasm of his flock in 403, and Arcadius and Eudoxia cowering
before the power of Holy Church like Henry IV. at Canossa in 1077. The
true picture of the three years of agony which preceded the old
man’s passage to the better world in 407 is a painful contrast to
contemplate (Pallad. Dial. 1–3. Theodoret V. 34. Sozomen viii.
26, 27, 28.) Of Theodoret’s restoration to “ecclesiastical
dignity,” and Leo’s part in it, we shall see further
on.