Doocvi|[]] ARNOBIUS ADVERSUS GENTES. 905
lieve that they can purchase pardon for themselves (8). A protest is
put into the mouth of an ox against the injustice of compelling cattle
to pay the penalty of men's offences (9). Arnobius then points out
that the doctrine of fate, that all things proceed from causes, and that
therefore the course of events cannot be changed, does away with all
need to appeal to the gods to render services which are not in their
power (10). Finally, the miseries of men are a conclusive proof that
the gods cannot avert evil (11), otherwise they are ungrateful in allow-
ing misfortunes to overwhelm their worshippers. A brief résumé is
given of the preceding arguments, illustrated by the cases of two men,
of whom one has but little to give, whilst the other loads the altars with
his offerings ; and of two nations at war with each other whose gifts
are equal,—which show how untenable the hypothesis is, that sacrifices
purchase the favour of the gods (12).
Another pretext urged was, that the gods were honoured by the
offering of sacrifices. How could this be? Honour consists in some-
thing yielded and something received (13). But what could the gods
receive from men? how could their greatness be increased by men’s
actions (14)? The true deities should indeed be honoured by enter-
taining thoughts worthy of them ; but what kind of honour is it to slay
animals before them, to offer them blood, and send up wreaths of smoke
into the air (15)? Still, if such horrid sights and smells were thought
pleasing to the gods, why were certain animals and certain things
chosen to be sacrificed, and not others (16) ? The absurdity of offering
to the gods the food used by us, is shown by supposing that pigs, dogs,
asses, swallows, and other birds and beasts, were to sacrifice to men, in
like manner, flies, ants, hay, bones, and the filth even which some of
them eat (17). It is then asked why to one god bulls were sacrificed,
to another kids, to a third sheep; to some white, to others black, to
some male, to others female animals (18). The usual answer was, that
to the gods male victims, to the goddesses females, were sacrificed, which
brings up again the question as to sex amongst the deities. But pass-
ing this by, what is there in difference of colour to make the gods
pleased or displeased as the victim might be white or black? The gods
of heaven, it might be said, delight in cheerful colours, those of Hades in
gloomy ones. In the time of Arnobius, however, few believed that there
was any such place as Hades; and if this were so, there could be no gods
there (19). But conceding this point also, and admitting that to their
savage dispositions gloomy colours might be pleasing, Arnobius suggests
that only the skins of animals are black, and that therefore the flesh,
-bones, etc. should not be offered, nor the wine, milk, oil, and other
things used in sacrifices which are not black (20). It is next asked
why certain animals were sacrificed to certain gods, and not to others ;
to which the only answer is, that it had been so determined by the men
of former times (21). Or if it be suggested that a reason is seen in the
ARNOB., U