general. He brings even Mr. Humphrey (though opposite in judgment) for his voucher:
who acknowledges, that the visible church is defined by a profession of true regenerate faith,
and of no less than that, according to the most general opinion of protestant divines. He
speaks of it as the common opinion, that a profession of no less than true grace or justifying
faith is the rule of admission to the church-sacraments. And though Mr. Humphrey went
off from the received opinion, yet could he not come into Mr. Blake’s notions in this matter,
who also had gone off from it, nor hope for their vindication: hence he makes that challenge,
What man is there, that dares revive Mr. Blake’s cause, and defend it against Mr. Barter’s
right to sacraments?
Mr. Baxter in this his book very copiously argues a profession of saving faith, as the rule
of admission to the sacraments, and much insists on its being so by the unanimous consent
of judicious divines. He tells us, Mr. Gataker in his books has largely proved this by a mul-
titude of quotations from protestant writers. And he adds his own testimony, repeatedly
saying, It is indeed their most common doctrine—It is the common protestant doctrine. And
again, Certain I am, this is the common doctrine of reformed divines. He subjoins, I must
profess, that I do not know of any one protestant divine, reputed orthodox, of the contrary
judgment, before Dr. Ward and Mr. Blake, though some papists and Arminians I knew of
that mind. And again, (beside Sir Henry Vane,) he says, All that I know of, since Dr. Ward,
is Mr. Blake, Mr. Humphrey, and one John Timson; and John Timson, Mr. Humphrey, and
Mr. Blake. He alleges Mr. Vines, as thus witnessing in the case on his side. To this purpose
all our learned divines have given their suffrage: I need not authors or churches. It is so plain
a case, that I wonder those [of the contrary opinion] have not taken notice of it, there is an
army to a man against them.
Mr. Langley, in his Suspension Reviewed, observes, The concurrent judgment of divines,
English and foreign, episcopal and presbyterian, that a man of vast and digested reading,
the learned Mr. Baxter, hath demonstrated at large in sixty testimonies; sundry of which
have many in them, being the judgment of many churches and many learned men therein;
and more might easily be brought. In short, he calls it the old protestant doctrine asserted
against the papists; and wonders at the confidence of the men, who tell us, against our own
eyes, that it is a novelism.
To these attestations I subjoin that of our Mr. Mitchel, (in his introduction before the
Defence of the Synod, 1662,) who while asserting a different latitude of the two sacraments,
yet pleads for strictness in admissions to the Lord’s table; and testifies, It is most evident,
that godly reforming divines have in their doctrine unanimously taught, and in their practice
(many of them) endeavoured, a strict selection of those who should be admitted to the Lord’s
supper. I think it may he not improperly observed here, that in a manuscript, drawn up by
this eminent person for his own satisfaction, and inserted in the account of his life, he has
left his solemn testimony against a lax mode of profession, (exclusive of all examinations
1886
Appendix. Mr. Foxcroft's letter.