(b) The case of Arsenius. Arsenius was
Meletian bishop of Hypsele (not in the Meletian catalogue of 327). By a
large bribe, as it is stated, he was induced by John Arcaph to go into
hiding among the Meletian monks of the Thebaid; rumours were quietly
set in motion that Athanasius had had him murdered, and had procured
one of his hands for magical purposes. A hand was circulated purporting
to be the very hand in question. A report of the case, including the
last version of the Ischyras scandal, was sent to Constantine, who,
startled by the new accusation, sent orders to his half-brother,
Dalmatius, a high official at Antioch, to enquire into the case. He
appears to have suggested a council at Cæsarea under the
presidency of Eusebius, which was to meet at some time in the year 334
(πέρυσιν, p. 141, cf. note 2 there,
also Gwatkin, p. 84 note; the ‘30 months’ of Soz. ii. 25 is
an exaggeration). Athanasius, however, obstinately declined a trial
before a judge whom he regarded as biassed; his refusal bitterly
offended the aged historian. Accordingly the venue was fixed for
Tyre in the succeeding year; a Count Dionysius was to represent the
Emperor, and see that all was conducted fairly, and Athanasius was
stringently (p. 137) summoned to attend. Meanwhile a trusted deacon was on the
tracks of the missing man. Arsenius was traced to a
‘monastery’ of Meletian brethren in the nome of
Antæopolis in Upper Egypt. Pinnes, the presbyter of the community,
got wind of the discovery, and smuggled Arsenius away down the Nile;
presently he was spirited away to Tyre. The deacon, however, very
astutely made a sudden descent upon the monastery in force, seized
Pinnes, carried him to Alexandria, brought him before the
‘Duke,’ confronted him with the monk who had escorted
Arsenius away, and forced them to confess to the whole plot. As soon as
he was able to do so, Pinnes wrote to John Arcaph, warning him of the
exposure, and suggesting that the charge had better be dropped (p. 135;
the letter is an amusingly naive exhibition of human rascality).
Meanwhile (Socr. i. 29) Arsenius was heard of at an inn in Tyre by the
servant of a magistrate; the latter had him arrested, and informed
Athanasius Who
perhaps visited Tyre himself at this time, according to an allusion in
Hist. Aceph. xii., see Sievers, Einl. p. 131.. Arsenius stoutly denied his identity,
but was recognised by the bishop of Tyre, and at last confessed. The
Emperor was informed and wrote to Athanasius (p. 135), expressing his
indignation at the plot, as also did Alexander, bishop of Thessalonica.
Arsenius made his peace with Athanasius, and in due time succeeded
(according to the Nicene rule) to the sole episcopate of Hypsele (p.
548). John Arcaph even admitted his guilt and renounced his schisms and
was invited to Court (p. 136); but his submission was not
permanent.