15. The passages, however, which I have adduced in
support of my position and in which it is permitted to widows, if they
so desire, to marry again, are interpreted by some concerning those
widows who had lost their husbands and were found in that condition
when they became Christians. For, supposing a person baptized and her
husband dead, it would not be consistent if the Apostle were to bid her
marry another, when he enjoins even those who have wives to be as
though they had them not. And this is why the number of wives which a
man may take is not defined, because when Christian baptism has been
received, even though a third or a fourth wife has been taken, she is
reckoned as the first. Otherwise, if, after baptism and after the death
of a first husband, a second is taken why should not a sixth after the
death of the second, third, fourth, and fifth, and so on? For it is
possible, that through some strange misfortune, or by the judgement of
God cutting short repeated marriages, a young woman may have several
husbands, while an old woman may be left a widow by her first husband
in extreme age. The first Adam was married once: the second was
unmarried. Let the supporters of second marriages shew us as their
leader a third Adam who was twice married. But granted that Paul
allowed second marriages: upon the same grounds it follows that he
allows even third and fourth marriages, or a woman may marry as often
as her husband dies. The Apostle was forced to choose many things which
he did not like. He circumcised Timothy, and shaved his own head,
practised going barefoot, let his hair grow long, and cut it at
Cenchrea. And he had certainly chastised the Galatians, and blamed
Peter because for the sake of Jewish observances he separated himself
from the Gentiles. As then in other points connected with the
discipline of the Church he was a Jew to Jews, a Gentile to Gentiles,
and was made all things to all men, that he might gain all: so too he
allowed second marriages to incontinent persons, and did not limit the
number of marriages, in order that women, although they saw themselves
permitted to take a second husband, in the same way as a third or a
fourth was allowed, might blush to take a second, lest they should be
compared to those who were three or four times married. If more than
one husband be allowed, it makes no difference whether he be a second
or a third, because there is no longer a question of single marriage. 1 Cor. vi. 12.“All things are lawful, but not
all things are expedient.” I do not condemn second, nor third,
nor, pardon the expression, eighth marriages: I will go still further
and say that I welcome even a penitent whoremonger. Things that are
equally lawful must be weighed in an even balance.