The contradiction existing in these passages being thus evident, I
am inclined to admire for their acuteness those who praise this
doctrine. For it would be hard to say to which of his statements they
could turn without finding themselves at variance with the remainder.
His earlier statement represented that the generated essence, and the
appellation of “Son,” made such a relation of words
appropriate. His present system says the contrary:—that
“the Son possesses His relation to Him that begat Him without
community.” If they believe the first statement, they will surely
not accept the second: if they incline to the latter, they will find
themselves opposed to the earlier conception. Who will stay the combat?
Who will mediate in this civil war? Who will bring this discord into
agreement, when the very soul is divided against itself by the opposing
statements, and drawn in different ways to contrary doctrines? Perhaps
we may see here that dark saying of prophecy which David speaks of the
Jews—“They were divided but were not pricked at heart This is
the LXX. version of the last part of Ps. xxxv. 15, a rendering with
which the Vulgate version practically agrees..” For lo, not even when they are
divided among contrariety of doctrines have they a sense of their
discordancy, but they are carried about by their ears like wine-jars,
borne around at the will of him who shifts them. It pleased him to say
that the generated essence was closely connected with the appellation
of “Son”: straightway, like men asleep, they nodded assent
to his remarks. He changed his statement again to the contrary one, and
denies the relation of the Son to Him that begat Him: again his
well-beloved friends join in assent to this also, shifting in whatever
direction he chooses, as the shadows of bodies change their form by
spontaneous mimicry with the motion of the advancing figure, and even
if he contradicts himself, accepting that also. This is another form of
the drought that Homer tells us of, not changing the bodies of those
who drink its poison into the forms of brutes, but acting on their
souls to produce in them a change to a state void of reason. For of
those men, the tale tells that their mind was sound, while their form
was changed to that of beasts, but here, while their bodies remain in
their natural state, their souls are transformed to the condition of
brutes. And as there the poet’s tale of wonder says that those
who drank the drug were changed into the forms of various beasts, at
the pleasure of her who beguiled their nature, the same thing happens
now also from this Circe’s cup. For they who drink the deceit of
sorcery from the same writing are changed to different forms of
doctrine, transformed now to one, now to another. And meanwhile these
very ridiculous people, according to the revised edition of the fable,
are still well pleased with him who leads them to such absurdity, and
stoop to gather the words he scatters about, as if they were cornel
fruit or acorns, running greedily like swine to the doctrines that are
shed on the ground, not being naturally capable of fixing their gaze on
those which are lofty and heavenly. For this reason it is that they do
not see the tendency of his argument to contrary positions, but snatch
without examination what comes in their way: and as they say that the
bodies of men stupefied with mandrake are held in a sort of slumber and
inability to move, so are the senses of these men’s souls
affected, being made torpid as regards the apprehension of deceit. It
is certainly a terrible thing to be held in unconsciousness by hidden
guile, as the result of some fallacious argument: yet where it is
involuntary the misfortune is excusable: but to be brought to make
trial of evil as the result of a kind of forethought and zealous
desire, not in ignorance of what will befall, surpasses every extreme
of misery. Surely we may well complain, when we hear that even greedy
fish avoid the steel when it comes near them unbaited, and take down
the hook only when hope of food decoys them to a bait: but where the
evil is apparent, to go over of their own accord to this destruction is
a more wretched thing than the folly of the fish: for these are led by
their greediness to a destruction that is concealed from them, but the
others swallow with open mouth the hook of impiety in its bareness,
satisfied with destruction under the influence of some unreasoning
passion. For what could be clearer than this contradiction—than
to say that the same Person was begotten and is a thing created, and
that something is closely connected with the name of “Son,”
and, again, is alien from the sense of “Son”? But enough of
these matters.