Elucidations.
————————————
I.
(Arrangement, p. 4,
supra.)
The
arrangement I have
adopted in editing these Edinburgh Translations of Tertullian is a
practical one. It will be found logical and helpful to the student, who
is referred to the Prefatory pages of this volume for an Elucidation of
the difficulties, with which any arrangement of these treatises is
encumbered. For,
first
, an attempt to place them in
chronological order is out of the question;
154
and,
second
, all efforts to separate precisely the Orthodox from the
Montanistic or Montanist works of our author have hitherto defied the
acumen of critics. It would be mere empiricism for me to attempt
an original classification in the face of questions which even experts
have been unable to determine.
If we bear in mind, however, a few guiding facts,
we shall see that difficulties are less than might appear, assuming our
object to be a practical one. (1.) Only
four
of these essays
were written against Orthodoxy; (2.)
five
more are reckoned as
wholly uncertain, which amounts to saying that they are not positively
heretical. (3.) Again,
five
are colourless, as to Montanism, and
hence should be reputed Orthodox. (4.) Of others, written after
the influences of Montanism had, more or less, tainted his doctrine,
the whole are yet valuable and some are noble defences of the Catholic
Faith. (5.) Finally eight or ten of his treatises were written while he
was a Catholic, and are precious contributions to the testimony of the
Primitive Church.
From these facts, we may readily conclude that the
mass of Tertullian’s writings is Orthodox. Some of them are
to be read with caution; others, again, must be rejected for their
heresy; but yet all are most instructive historically, and as defining
even by errors “the faith once delivered to the Saints.” I
propose to note those which require caution as we pass them in review.
Those written against the Church are classed by themselves, at the end
of the list, and all the rest may be read with confidence. A most
interesting inquiry arises in connection with the quotations from
Scripture to be found in our author. Did a Latin version exist in his
day, or does he translate from the Greek of the New Testament and the
LXX
? A paradoxical writer (Semler) contends
that Tertullian “never used a Greek
ms.
” (see Kaye, p. 106.) But Tertullian’s
rugged Latin betrays everywhere his familiarity with Greek idioms and
forms of thought. He wrote, also, in Greek, and there is no reason to
doubt that he knew the Greek Scriptures primarily, if he knew any Greek
whatever. Possibly we owe to Tertullian the
primordia
of
the Old African Latin Versions, some of which seem to have contained
the disputed text
1 John v.
7
; of which more when
we come to the Praxeas. For the present in the absence of definite
evidence we must infer that Tertullian usually translated from the
LXX
, and from the originals of the New
Testament. But Mosheim thinks the progress of the Gospel in the West
was now facilitated by the existence of Latin Versions. Observe,
also, Kaye’s important note, p. 293, and his reference to
Lardner,
Cred.
xxvii. 19.
II.
(Address to Magistrates, cap. i., p. 17.)
The Apology comes first in order, on logical grounds. It
is classed with our author’s orthodox works by Neander, and
pronounced colourless by Kaye. It is the noblest of his
productions in its purpose and spirit, and it
falls in with the Primitive System of Apologetics. I have placed next
in order to it several treatises, mostly unblemished, which are of the
same character; which defend the cause of Christians against Paganism,
against Gentile Philosophy, and against Judaism; closing this portion
by the two books
Ad Nationes
, which may be regarded as a
recapitulation of the author’s arguments, especially those to be
found in the Apology. In these successive works, as compared with those
of Justin Martyr, we obtain a fair view of the progressive relations of
the Church with the Roman Empire and with divers antagonistic systems
in the East and West.
III.
(History of Christians, cap. ii., p. 18.)
The following Chronological outline borrowed from
the Benedictines and from Bishop Kaye, will prove serviceable
here.
155
Tertullian born (
circa
)
a.d.
150.
Tertullian converted (
surmise
) 185.
Tertullian married (
say
) 186.
Tertullian ordained presbyter (
circa
) 192.
Tertullian lapsed (
circa
) 200.
Tertullian deceased (extreme surmise) 240.
The Imperial history of his period may be thus
arranged:
Birth of Caracalla
a.d.
188.
Birth of Geta 189.
Reign of Severus 193.
Defeat of Niger 195.
Caracalla made a
Cæsar
196.
Capture of Byzantium 196.
Defeat of Albinus 197.
Geta made a
Cæsar
198.
Caracalla called
Augustus
198.
Caracalla associated in the Empire 198.
War against the Parthians 198.
Severus returns from the war 203.
Celebration of the Secular Games 204.
Plautianus put to death (
circa
) 205.
Geta called
Augustus
208.
War in Britain 208.
Wall of Severus 210.
Death of Severus 211.
IV.
(Tiberius, capp. v. and xxiv., pp. 22 and 35.)
A fair examination of what has been said on this
subject,
pro
and
con
, may be found in Kaye’s
Tertullian
,
156
pp. 102–105. In
his abundant candour this author leans to the doubters, but in stating
the case he seems to me to fortify the position of Lardner and
Mosheim. What the brutal Tiberius may have thought or done with
respect to Pilate’s report concerning the holy victim of his
judicial injustice is of little importance to the believer.
Nevertheless, as matter of history it deserves attention. Great stress
is to be placed on the fact that Tertullian was probably a
jurisconsult, familiar with the Roman archives, and influenced
by
them in his own
acceptance of Divine Truth. It is not supposable that such a man would
have hazarded his bold appeal to the records, in remonstrating with the
Senate and in the very faces of the Emperor and his colleagues, had he
not known that the evidence was irrefragable.
V.
(The darkness at the Crucifixion, cap. xxi., p. 35.)
Kaye disappoints us (p. 150) in his slight notice
of this most interesting subject. Without attempting to discuss the
story of Phlegon and other points which afford Gibbon an opportunity
for misplaced sneering, such as even a Pilate would have rebuked, while
it may be well to recall the exposition of Milman,
157
at the close of Gibbon’s fifteenth chapter, I must express my own
preference for another view. This will be found candidly summed up and
stated, in the Speaker’s Commentary, in the concise note on St.
Matt. xxvii. 45
.
VI.
(Numbers of the Faithful, cap. xxxvii., p. 45.)
Kaye, as usual, gives this vexed question a candid
survey.
158
Making all allowances, however, I accept the
conjecture of some reputable authorities, that there were 2,000,000 of
Christians, in the bounds of the Roman Empire at the close of the
Second Century. So mightily grew the testimony of Jesus and prevailed.
When we reflect that only a century intervened between the times of
Tertullian and the conversion of the Roman Emperor, it is not easy to
regard our author’s language as merely that of fervid genius and
of rhetorical hyperbole. He could not have ventured upon exaggeration
without courting scorn as well as defeat. What he affirms is
probable in the nature of the case. Were it otherwise, then the
conditions, which, in a single century rendered it possible for
Constantine to effect the greatest revolution in mind and manners that
has ever been known among men, would be a miracle compared with which
that of his alleged Vision of the Cross sinks into insignificance. To
this subject it will be necessary to recur hereafter.
VII.
(Christian usages, cap. xxxix., p. 46.)
A candid review of the matters discussed in this chapter
will be found in Kaye (pp. 146, 209.) The important fact is there
clearly stated that “the primitive Christians scrupulously
complied with the decree pronounced by the Apostles at Jerusalem in
abstaining from things strangled and from blood” (
Acts xv. 20
). On this subject consult the references
given in the Speaker’s Commentary,
ad locum
. The
Greeks, to their honour, still maintain this prohibition, but St.
Augustine’s great authority relaxed the Western scruples on this
matter, for he regarded it as a decree of temporary obligation, while
the Hebrew and Gentile Christians were in peril of misunderstanding and
estrangement.
159
On the important question as to the cessation of
miracles Kaye takes a somewhat original position. But see his
interesting discussion and that of the late Professor Hey, in
Kaye’s
Tertullian
, pp. 80–102, 151–161. I do
not think writers on these subjects have sufficiently distinguished
between
miracles
properly so called, and
providences
vouchsafed in answer to prayer. There was no
miracle
in the case
of the Thundering Legion, assuming the story to be true; and I dare to
affirm that marked answers to prayer, by
providential
interpositions
,
but wholly distinct from miraculous
agencies, have never ceased among those who “ask in the
Son’s Name.” Such interpositions are often
preternatural
only; that is, they economize certain powers
which, though natural in themselves, lie outside of the System of
Nature with which we happen to be familiar. This distinction has been
overlooked.
VIII.
(Multitudes, cap. xl., p. 47.)
Note the words—“
multitudes
to a
single beast.” Can it be possible that Tertullian would use such
language to the magistrates, if he knew that such sentences were of
rare occurrence? The disposition of our times to
minimize
the
persecutions of our Christian forefathers calls upon us to note such
references, all the more important because occurring
obiter
and
mentioned as notorious. Note also, the closing chapter of this Apology,
and reference to the outcries of the populace, in Cap. xxxv.
160
See admirable remarks on the benefits derived
by the Church from the sufferings of Christian martyrs, with direct
reference to Tertullian, Wordsworth,
Church Hist. to Council of
Nicæa
, cap. xxiv., p. 374.
IX.
(Christian manners, cap. xlii., p. 49.)
A study of the manners of Christians, in the
Ante-Nicene Age, as sketched by the unsparing hand of Tertullian, will
convince any unprejudiced mind of the mighty power of the Holy Ghost,
in framing such characters out of heathen originals. When, under
Montanistic influences our severely ascetic author complains of the
Church’s corruptions, and turns inside-out the whole estate of
the faithful, we see all that can be pressed on the other side; but,
this very important chapter must be borne in mind, together with the
closing sentence of chap. xliv., as evidence that whatever might be
said by a rigid disciplinarian, the Church,
as compared with
our
day, was still a living embodiment of
Philippians iv. 8
.
X.
(Paradise, cap. xlvii., p. 52.)
See Kaye, p. 248. Our author seems not always
consistent with himself in his references to the Places of departed
spirits. Kaye thinks he identifies Paradise with the Heaven of the Most
High, in one place (the
De Exhort. Cast.
, xiii.) where he
probably confuses the Apostle’s ideas, in
Galatians v. 12
, and
Ephesians v. 5
.
Commonly
, however, though
he is not consistent with himself, this would be his
scheme:—
1. The
Inferi
, or
Hades
, where the
soul of Dives was in one continent and that of Lazarus in another, with
a gulf between. Our author places “Abraham’s bosom”
in Hades.
2.
Paradise
. In Hades, but in a superior
and more glorious region. This more blessed abode was opened to the
souls of the martyrs and other greater saints, at our Lord’s
descent into the place of the dead. After the General
Resurrection and Judgment, there remain:
1.
Gehenna
, for the lost, prepared for the
devil and his angels.
2. The
Heaven of Heavens
, the eternal abode
of the righteous, in the vision of the Lord and His Eternal
Joy.
Tertullian’s variations on this subject will force
us to recur to it hereafter; but, here it may be noted that the
confusions of Latin Christianity received their character in this
particular, from the genius of our author. Augustine caught from him a
certain indecision
about the terms
and places connected with the state of the departed which has
continued, to this day, to perplex theologians in the West. Taking
advantage of such confusions, the stupendous Roman system of
“Purgatory” was fabricated in the middle ages; but the
Greeks never accepted it, and it differs fundamentally from what the
earlier Latin Fathers, including Tertullian, have given us as
speculations.
XI.
(The Leo and the Leno, cap. l., p. 55.)
Here we find the alliterative and epigrammatic genius of
Tertullian anticipating a similar poetic charm in Augustine. The
Christian maid or matron preferred the
Leo
to the
leno
;
to be devoured rather than to be debauched. Our author wrests a tribute
to the chastity of Christian women from the cruelty of their judges,
who recognizing this fact, were accustomed as a refinement of their
injustice to give sentence against them, refusing the mercy of a
horrible death, by committing them to the ravisher:
“damnando Christianam
ad lenonem
potius quam
ad
leonem
.”
XII.
(The Seed of the Church, cap. l., p. 55.)
Kaye has devoted a number of his pages
161
to the elucidation of this subject, not only
showing the constancy of the martyrs, but illustrating the fact that
Christians, like St. Paul, were forced to “die daily,” even
when they were not subjected to the fiery trial. He who confessed
himself a Christian made himself a social outcast. All manner of
outrages and wrongs could be committed against him with impunity. Rich
men, who had joined themselves to Christ,
162
were
forced to accept “the spoiling of their goods.” Brothers
denounced brothers, and husbands their wives; “a man’s foes
were they of his own household.” But the Church triumphed through
suffering, and “out of weakness was made
strong.”
154
Kaye, p. 36. Also,
p. 8,
supra
.
155
Kaye (following
L’Art de verifier les Dates
) pp. 11
and 456.
156
My references are to the
Third Edition, London, Rivingtons, 1845.
157
In his edition of The
Decline and Fall, Vol. I., p. 589, American reprint.
158
pp. 85–88.
159
Ep.
ad Faust
.
xxxii. 13. and see Conybeare and Howson.
160
Compare Kaye on Mosheim,
p. 107.
161
pp. 129–140.
162
Even under Commodus,
vol. ii. p. 598, this series.