Thus the whole work was completed between the
years 426 and 428; and now Cassian, who was growing old, was desirous
of rest, feeling as if his life’s work was nearly over. See the Preface
to the work On the Incarnation against Nestorius. But the repose which he sought was not to be
granted to him, for the remaining years of his life were troubled by
two controversies,—the Nestorian, and the Pelagian,—or,
rather, its offshoot, the Semi-Pelagian. Into the history of the former
of these there is no need to enter here in detail. It broke out at
Constantinople, where Nestorius had become bishop in succession to
Sisinnius, in 428. The immediate occasion which gave rise to the
controversy was a sermon by Anastasius, the Bishop’s chaplain, in
which he inveighed against the title Theotocos, as given to the Blessed
Virgin Mary. This at once created a great sensation, as Nestorius
warmly supported his chaplain, and proceeded to develop the heresy
connected with his name, in a course of sermons. News of the
controversy was brought to Egypt, and Cyril of Alexandria at once
entered into the fray. After some correspondence between the two
bishops, both parties endeavoured to gain the adherence of the Church
of Rome early in the year 430; and now it was that Cassian became mixed
up with the dispute. Greek learning was evidently at a low ebb in the
Roman Church at this time; See the Epistle of
Celestine to Nestorius in Mansi IV. 1026, in which he apologizes for
delay by saying that the letter and other documents sent by Nestorius
had had to be translated into Latin. and it was, perhaps,
partly owing to Cassian’s familiar acquaintance with this
language, as well as owing to his connexion with Constantinople, where
the trouble had now arisen, that Celestine’s Archdeacon Leo
turned to him at this crisis for help. Anyhow, whatever was the reason,
an earnest appeal from Rome reached him, begging him to write a
refutation of the new heresy. After some hesitation he consented, and
the result of his labours is seen in the seven books on the Incarnation
against Nestorius. The work was evidently done in haste, and published
in 430, before the Council of Ephesus (for Cassian speaks of Nestorius
throughout as still Bishop of Constantinople), and, judging from the
way in which Augustine is spoken of in VII. xxvii., before the death of
that Father, which took place in August, 430. A great part of the work
is occupied with Scripture proof of our Lord’s Divinity and unity
of Person; but, taken as a whole, the treatise is distinctly of less
value than Cassian’s earlier writings, and betrays the haste in
which it was composed by the occasional use of inaccurate language on
the subject of the Incarnation, and of terms and phrases which the
mature judgment of the Church has rejected. But the writer’s keen
penetration is seen by the quickness with which he connects the new
heresy with the teaching of Pelagius, the connecting link between the
two being found in the errors of Leporius of Trêves, who, in
propagating Pelagian views of man’s sufficiency and strength, had
applied them to the case of our Lord, not shrinking from the conclusion
that He was a mere man who had used his free will so well as to have
lived without sin, and had only been made Christ in virtue of His
baptism, whereby the Divine and human were associated in such manner
that virtually there were two Christs. See On the
Incarnation, Book I. c. ii. sq. The
connexion between Nestorianism and Pelagianism has often been noticed
by later writers, but to Cassian belongs the credit of having been the
first to point it out. Of the impression produced by his book we have
no record. He appears to have taken no further part in the controversy,
which, indeed, must have been to him an episode, coming in the midst of
that other controversy with which his name is inseparably associated;
viz., that on Semi-Pelagianism, on which something must now be
said.