Elucidations.
————————————
I.
(Prescription, Chap. I., p. 243,
Supra
.
)
In adopting this expression from the Roman Law,
Tertullian has simply puzzled beginners to get at his idea. Nor do they
learn much when it is called a
demurrer
, which, if I comprehend
the word as used in law-cases, is a rejoinder to the testimony of the
other party, amounting to—“Well, what of it? It does not
prove your case.” Something like this is indeed in
Tertullian’s use of the term
præscription
; but Dr.
Holmes furnishes what seems to me the best explanation, (though he only
half renders it,) “the Prescriptive Rule against Heresies.”
In a word, it means, “
the Rule of Faith
asserted against
Heresies.” And his practical point is, it is useless to discuss
Scripture with convicted (
Titus iii. 10, 11
.) heretics; every one of them is ready
with “his psalm, his doctrine, his interpretation,” and you
may argue fruitlessly till Doomsday. But bring them to the test of
(
Quod Semper
, etc.), the apostolic
præscription
(
1 Corinthians xi. 16
).—
We have no such custom
neither the Churches of God
. State this
Rule of Faith
, viz.
Holy Scripture, as interpreted from the apostolic day: if it proves the
doctrine or custom a
novelty
, then it has no foundation, and
even if it be harmless, it cannot be innocently professed against the
order and peace of the churches.
II.
(Semler, cap. x., note 15, p. 248.)
The extent to which Bp. Kaye has stretched his
notice of this critic is to be accounted for by the fact that, for a
time, the German School of the last century exerted a sad influence in
England. In early life Dr. Pusey came near to being led away by it, and
Hugh James Rose was raised up to resist it. Semler lived (at Halle and
elsewhere) from
a.d.
1725 to 1791. Kahnis in
his invaluable manual, named below, thus speaks of his Patristic
theories: “The history of the Kingdom of God became, under his
hands, a world of atoms, which crossed each other as chaotically as the
masses of notes which lay heaped up in the memory of
Semler.…Under his pragmatical touches the halo of the martyrs
faded, etc.”
Internal Hist. of German Protestantism
(since
circa
1750, ) by Ch. Fred. Aug. Kahnis, D.D. (Lutheran)
Professor at Leipzig. Translated. T. and F. Clark, Edinburgh,
1856.
III.
(Peter, cap. xxii. note 6, p. 253.)
In the treatise of Cyprian,
De Unitate
, we
shall have occasion to speak fully on this interesting point. The
reference to Kaye may suffice, here. But, since the inveterate
confusion of all that is said of Peter with all that is claimed by a
modern bishop for himself promotes a false view of this passage, it may
be well to note (1) that St. Peter’s name is expounded by himself
(
1 Peter ii. 4,
5
) so as to make Christ
the Rock and
all believers
“lively stones”—or
Peters
—by faith in Him. St. Peter is often called
the
rock
, most justly, in this sense, by a rhetorical play on his name:
Christ the Rock and all believers “
lively stones
,”
being cemented with Him by the Spirit. But, (2) this
specialty
of St. Peter, as such, belongs to him (
Cephas
)
only. (3) So far as transmitted it belongs to no particular See. (4)
The claim of Rome is disproved by
Præscription
. (5) Were it
otherwise, it would not justify that See in making new articles of
Faith. (6) Nor in its Schism with the East. (7) When it
restores St. Peter’s Doctrine and Holiness, to the Latin
Churches, there will be no quarrel about pre-eminence. Meantime,
Rome’s
fallibility
is expressly taught in
Romans xi.
18–21
.
IV.
(The Apostles, cap. xxv. p. 254.)
Nothing less than a new incarnation of Christ and
a new commission to new apostles can give us anything new in religion.
This
præscription
is our Catholic answer to the Vatican
oracles of our own time. These give us a new revelation, prefacing the
Gospels (1) by defining the
immaculate conception
of Mary in the
womb of her mother; and (2) adding a new chapter to the Acts of the
Apostles, in defining the infallibility of a single bishop.
Clearly, had Tertullian known anything of this last
dogma of Latin Novelty, he would not have taken the trouble to write
this treatise. He would have said to heretics, We can neither discuss
Scripture nor Antiquity with you. Rome is the touchstone of dogma, and
to its bishop we refer you.
V.
(Truth and Peace, cap. xliv. p. 265.)
The famous appeal of Bishop Jewel, known as
“the Challenge at Paul’s Cross,” which he made in a
sermon preached there on Passion Sunday,
a.d.
1560, is an instance of “
Præscription
against
heresies,” well worthy of being recalled, in a day which has seen
Truth and Peace newly sacrificed to the ceaseless innovations of Rome.
It is as follows:—“If any learned man of all our
adversaries, or, if all the learned men that be alive, be able to
bring
any one sufficient
sentence
out of any old Catholic doctor or father; or out of
any old general Council; or out of the Holy Scriptures of God;
2313
or, any
one example
of the primitive
Church, whereby it may be clearly and plainly proved,
that—
1. There was any private mass in the whole world at that
time, for the space of six hundred years after Christ; or
that—
2. There was then any communion ministered unto the
people under one kind; or that—
3. The people had their common prayers, then, in a
strange tongue that they understood not; or that—
4. The bishop of Rome was then called an universal
bishop, or the head of the universal Church; or that—
5. The people was then taught to believe that
Christ’s body is really, substantially, corporally, carnally or
naturally in the Sacrament; or that—
6. His body is, or may be, in a thousand places or more,
at one time; or that—
7. The priest did then hold up the Sacrament over his
head; or that—
8. The people did then fall down and worship it with
godly honour; or that—
9. The Sacrament was then, or now ought to be, hanged up
under a canopy; or that—
10. In the Sacrament after the words of
consecration there remaineth only the
accidents
and shews,
without the
substance
of bread and wine; or
that—
11. The priest then divided the Sacrament in three parts
and afterwards received himself, alone; or that—
12. Whosoever had said the Sacrament is a pledge, a
token, or a remembrance of Christ’s body, had therefore been
judged a heretic; or that—
13. It was lawful, then, to have thirty, twenty,
fifteen, ten, or five masses said in one Church, in one day; or
that—
14. Images were then set up in churches to the intent
the people might worship them; or that—
15. The lay people was then forbidden to read the word
of God, in their own tongue:
“If any man alive be able to prove any of these
articles, by any one clear or plain clause or sentence, either of the
Scriptures, or of the old doctors, or of any old General Council, or by
any Example of the Primitive Church; I promise, then, that I will give
over and subscribe unto him.”
All this went far beyond the concession of
præscription
which makes little of
any one saying of any
one Father
, and demands the general consent of Antiquity; but, it
is needless to say that Jewel’s challenge has remained unanswered
for more than three hundred years, and so it will be to all
Eternity.
With great erudition Jewel enlarged his
propositions and maintained all his points. See his works, vol. I., p.
20
et seqq
. Cambridge University Press, 1845.
2313
It must be remembered
that an appeal to Scripture lies behind Tertullian’s
Præscription
: only he will not discuss Holy Scripture with
heretics.