1. Thou hast done well,
in signifying to me the discussion thou hast had with the advocates of
Arianism, among whom were certain of the friends of Eusebius, as well
as very many of the brethren who hold the doctrine of the Church. I
hailed thy vigilance for the love of Christ, which excellently exposed
the irreligion εὐσέβεια,
ἀσέβεια,
&c., here translated “religion, irreligion, religious,
&c. &c.” are technical words throughout, being taken from
S. Paul’s text, “Great is the mystery of
godliness,” εὐσεβείας, i.e. orthodoxy. Such too seems to be the meaning of
“godly admonitions,” and “godly judgments,” and
“this godly and well-learned man,” in our Ordination
Services. The Latin translation is “pius,”
“pietas.” It might be in some respects suitably rendered by
“devout” and its derivatives. On its familiar use in the
controversy depends the blasphemous jest of Eudoxius, Arian Bishop of
Constantinople, which was received with loud laughter in the Cathedral,
and remained in esteem down to Socrates’ day, “The Father
is ἀσεβὴς, as
being without devotion, the Son εὐσεβὴς, devout, as paying devotion to the Father.” Socr.
Hist. ii. 43. Hence Arius ends his Letter to Eusebius
with ἀληθως
εὐσέβιε.
Theod. Hist. i. 4. of their heresy; while I marvelled at
the effrontery which led the Arians, after all the past detection of
unsoundness and futility in their arguments, nay, after the general
conviction of their extreme perverseness, still to complain like the
Jews, “Why did the Fathers at Nicæa use terms not in
Scripture It
appears that the Arians did not venture to speak disrespectfully of the
definition of the Council till the date (a.d.
352) of this work, when Acacius headed them. Yet the plea here used,
the unscriptural character of its symbol, had been suggested to
Constantius on his accession, a.d. 337, by the
Arian priest, the favourite of Constantia, to whom Constantine had
entrusted his will, Theod. Hist. ii. 3; and Eusebius of
Cæsarea glances at it, at the time of the Council, in the letter
to his Church, which is subjoined to this Treatise., ‘Of the essence’ and
‘One in essence?’” Thou then, as a man of learning,
in spite of their subterfuges, didst convict them of talking to no
purpose; and they in devising them were but acting suitably to their
own evil disposition. For they are as variable and fickle in their
sentiments, as chameleons in their colours Alexander also calls them chameleons, Socr. i. 6. p. 12.
Athanasius so calls the Meletians, Hist. Arian. §79. Cyril
compares them to “the leopard which cannot change his
spots.” Dial. ii. init. t. v. i. Aub., Naz. Or. 28. 2. On
the fickleness of the Arians, vid. infra, §4. &c. Orat.
ii. 40. He says, ad Ep. Æg. 6. that they considered Creeds
as yearly covenants; and de Synod. §3. 4. as State Edicts.
vid. also §14. and passim. “What wonder that they
fight against their fathers, when they fight against themselves?”
§37.; and
when exposed they look confused, and when questioned they hesitate, and
then they lose shame, and betake themselves to evasions. And then, when
detected in these, they do not rest till they invent fresh matters
which are not, and, according to the Scripture, ‘imagine a vain
thing Ps. ii. 1.’; and all that they may be constant to
their irreligion.