Introductory Notice
to
The Recognitions of
Clement.
[By the Translator, Rev. Thomas Smith,
D.D.]
————————————
The
Recognitions of
Clement
is a kind of philosophical and theological romance.
The writer of the work seems to have had no intention of presenting his
statements as facts; but, choosing the disciples of Christ and their
followers as his principal characters, he has put into their mouths the
most important of his beliefs, and woven the whole together by a thread
of fictitious narrative.
The
Recognitions
is one of a series; the
other members of which that have come down to us are the
Clementine
Homilies
and two
Epitomes
.
521
The authorship, the date, and the doctrinal
character of these books have been subjects of keen discussion in
modern times. Especial prominence has been given to them by the
Tübingen school. Hilgenfeld says: “There is
scarcely a single writing which is of so great importance for the
history of Christianity in its first stage, and which has already given
such brilliant disclosures at the hands of the most renowned critics in
regard to the earliest history of the Christian Church, as the writings
ascribed to the Roman Clement, the
Recognitions
and
Homilies
.”
522
The
importance thus attached to these strange and curious documents by one
school of theologians, has compelled men of all shades of belief to
investigate the subject; but after all their investigations, a great
variety of opinion still prevails on almost every point connected with
these books.
We leave our readers to judge for themselves in
regard to the doctrinal statements, and confine ourselves to a notice
of some of the opinions in regard to the authorship and date of the
Recognitions
.
523
The first question that suggests itself in regard
to the
Recognitions
is, whether the
Recognitions
or the
Homilies
are the earliest form of the book, and what relation do
they bear to each other? Some maintain that they are both the
productions of the same author, and that the one is a later and altered
edition of the other; and they find some confirmation of this in the
preface of Rufinus. Others think that both books are expansions
of another work which formed the basis. And others maintain that
the one book is a
rifacimento
of the other by a
different hand. Of this third party, some, like Cave, Whiston,
Rosenmüller, Staüdlin, Hilgenfeld, and many others, believe
that the
Recognitions
was the earliest
524
of
the two forms; while others, as Clericus, Möhler, Lücke,
Schliemann, and Uhlhorn, give priority to the
Clementines
.
Hilgenfeld supposes that the original writing was the
Κήρυγμα
Πέτρου
, which still remains
in the work; that besides this there are three parts,—one
directed against Basilides, the second the
Travels of Peter
(
περίοδοι
)
and the third the
Recognitions
. There are also, he
believes, many interpolated passages of a much later date than any of
these parts.
525
No conclusion has
been reached in regard to the author. Some have believed that it
is a genuine work of Clement. Whiston maintained that it was
written by some of his hearers and companions. Others have
attributed the work to Bardesanes. But most acknowledge that
there is no possibility of discovering who was the author.
Various opinions exist as to the date of the
book. It has been attributed to the first, second, third, and
fourth centuries, and some have assigned even a later date. If we
were to base our arguments on the work as it stands, the date assigned
would be somewhere in the first half of the third century. A
passage from the
Recognitions
is quoted by Origen
526
in his
Commentary on Genesis
,
written in 231; and mention is made in the work of the extension of the
Roman franchise to all nations under the dominion of Rome,—an
event which took place in the region of Caracalla,
a.d.
211. The
Recognitions
also contains a
large extract from the work
De Fato
, ascribed to Bardesanes, but
really written by a scholar of his. Some have thought that
Bardesanes or his scholar borrowed from the
Recognitions
; but
more recently the opinion has prevailed, that the passage was not
originally in the
Recognitions
, but was inserted in the
Recognitions
towards the middle of the third century, or even
later.
527
Those who believe the work made up of various documents
assign various dates to these documents. Hilgenfeld, for
instance, believes that the
Κήρυγμα
Πέτρου
was written before
the time of Trojan, and the
Travels of Peter
about the time of
his reign.
Nothing is known of the place in which the
Recognitions
was written. Some, as Schliemann, have
supposed Rome, some Asia Minor, and recently Uhlhorn has tried to trace
it to Eastern Syria.
528
The Greek of the
Recognitions
is
lost. The work has come down to us in the form of a translation
by Rufinus of Aquileia (
d
. 410
a.d.).
In his letter to Gaudentius, Rufinus states
that he omitted some portions difficult of comprehension, but that in
regard to the other parts he had translated with care, and an endeavour
to be exact even in rendering the phraseology.
The best editions of the
Recognitions
are
those by Cotelerius, often reprinted, and by Gersdorf, Lipsiæ,
1838; but the text is not in a satisfactory
condition.
521
[See
supra
, p. 69, and Introductory Notice to
Homilies
.—R.]
522
Die
Clementinischen Rekognitionen und Homilien, nach ihrem Ursprung und
Inhalt dargestellt
, von Dr. Adolf Hilgenfeld, Jena,
1848, p. 1. [Despite the morbid taste of this school for
heretical writings, and the now proven incorrectness of the
“tendency-theory,” due credit must be given to Baur and his
followers for awakening a better critical discernment among the
students of ecclesiastical history. Hilgenfeld’s judgments,
in the higher and lower criticism also, are frequently very incorrect;
but he has done much to further a correct estimate of the
Clementina
. See Introductory Notice,
supra
.—R.]
523
[The title,
which varies in different manuscripts, is derived from the
“narrating, in the last books, of the re-union of the scattered
members of the Clementine family, who all at last find themselves
together in Christianity, and are baptized by Peter” (Schaff,
History
).—R.]
524
See Schliemann,
Die Clementinen
, Hamburg, 1844, p. 295.
525
[See a brief
account of the discussion
supra
, p, 70.—R.]
526
Philocalia
,
cap. 22.
527
See Merx,
Bardesanes von Edessa
, Halle, 1863, p.
113.
528
Die Homilien und Rekognitionen des Clemens Romanus, nach ihrem
Ursprung und Inhalt dargestellt
, von Gerhard Uhlhorn,
Göttingen, 1854, p. 429. [Schaff thinks “the
Homilies
probably originated in East Syria, the Recognitions in
Rome.” But Rufinus gives no intimation of the Roman origin
of the Greek work he translated. Still, the apparently more
orthodox character of the
Recognitions
suggests an editor from
the Western Church.—R.]