Now if we loudly preach all
this, and testify to all this, namely that Christ is the power of God
and the wisdom of God, always changeless, always imperishable, though
He comes in the changeable and the perishable; never stained Himself,
but making clean that which is stained; what is the crime that we
commit, and wherefore are we hated? And what means this opposing
array ἀντεξαγωγὴ of new Altars? Do we announce another Jesus?
Do we hint at another? Do we produce other scriptures? Have any of
ourselves dared to say “Mother of Man” of the Holy Virgin,
the Mother of God As
early as 250, Dionysius of Alexandria, in his letter to Paul of
Samosata, frequently speaks of ἡ θεοτόκος
Μαρία. Later, in the
Council of Ephesus (430), it was decreed that “the immaculate and
ever-Virgin mother of our Lord should be called properly (κυρίως) and really θεοτόκος,” against the Nestorian title χριστοτόκος. Cf. Theodoret. Anath. I. tom. iv. p. 709,
“We call Mary not Mother of Man, but Mother of God;” and
Greg. Naz. Or. li. p. 738. “If any one call not Mary
Mother of God he is outside ‘divinity.’”: which is what we
hear that some of them say without restraint? Do we romance about three
Resurrections μὴ τρεῖς
ἀναστάσεις
μυθοποιοῦμεν; For the first Resurrection (of the Soul in Baptism) and
the second (of the Body), see Rev. xx. 5, with Bishop
Wordsworth’s note.? Do we promise the
gluttony of the Millennium? Do we declare that the Jewish
animal-sacrifices shall be restored? Do we lower men’s hopes
again to the Jerusalem below, imagining its rebuilding with stones of a
more brilliant material? What charge like these can be brought against
us, that our company should be reckoned a thing to be avoided, and that
in some places another altar should be erected in opposition to us, as
if we should defile their sanctuaries? My heart was in a state of
burning indignation about this: and now that I have set foot in the
City i.e.Cæsarea in
Cappadocia. again, I am eager to unburden my soul of its
bitterness, by appealing, in a letter, to your love. Do ye,
whithersoever the Holy Spirit shall lead you, there remain; walk with
God before you; confer not with flesh and blood; lend no occasion to
any of them for glorying, that they may not glory in you, enlarging
their ambition by anything in your lives. Remember the Holy Fathers,
into whose hands ye were commended by your Father now in bliss Basil, probably: who after Cyril’s exile had been called in
to heal the heresy of Apollinaris, which was spreading in the convents
at Jerusalem. The factious purism, however, which Gregory deplores
here, and which led to rival altars, seems to have evinced itself
amongst the orthodox themselves, “quo majorem apud omnes
opinionem de suâ præstantiâ belli isti cathari
excitarent” (Casaubon). Cyril, it is true, had returned this
year, 382; and spent the last years of his life in his see; but with
more than twenty years interval of Arian rule (Herennius, Heraclius,
and Hilarius, according to Sozomen) the communities of the Catholics
must have suffered from want of a constant control: and unity was
always difficult to maintain in a city frequented by all the
ecclesiastics of the world. Gregory must have “succeeded”
to this charge in his visit to Jerusalem after the Council of Antioch
in 379, to which he refers in his letter On Pilgrimages: but it
is possible that he had paid even an earlier visit: see Letter XIV. p.
539, note 5., and to whom we by God’s grace were
deemed worthy to succeed and remove not the boundaries which our
Fathers have laid down, nor put aside in any way the plainness of our
simpler proclamation in favour of their subtler school. Walk by the
primitive rule of the Faith: and the God of peace shall be with you,
and ye shall be strong in mind and body. May God keep you uncorrupted,
is our prayer.