19. But as to that Epicurus himself, the defender of pleasure, of whom, therefore, we
have made frequent mention in order to prove that these men are either disciples of the
heathen and followers of the Epicurean sect or himself, whom the very philosophers exclude
from their company as the patron of luxury, what if we prove him to be more tolerable than
these men? He declares, as Demarchus267 asserts, that neither drinking, nor banquets, nor
offspring, nor embraces of women, nor abundance of fish, and other such like things which
are prepared for the service of a sumptuous banquet, make life sweet, but sober discussion.
Lastly, he added that those who do not use the banquets of society in excess, use them with
moderation. He who willingly makes use of the juices of plants alone together with bread
and water, despises feasts on delicacies, for many inconveniences arise from them. In another
place they also say: It is not excessive banquets, nor drinking which give rise to the enjoyment
of pleasure, but a life of temperance.
20. Since, then, philosophy has disowned those men, is the Church not to exclude them?
460
Seeing, too, that they, because they have a bad cause, frequently fall foul of themselves by
their own assertions. For, although their chief opinion is that there is no enjoyment of
pleasure except such as is derived from eating and drinking, yet understanding that they
cannot, without the greatest shame, cling to so disgraceful a definition, and that they are
forsaken by all, they have tried to colour it with a sort of stain of specious arguments; so
that one of them has said: Whilst we are aiming at pleasure by means of banquets and songs,
we have lost that which is infused into us by the reception of the Word, whereby alone we
can be saved.
21. Do not they by these various arguments show themselves to us as differing and dis-
agreeing one with the other? And Scripture too condemns them, not passing over those
whom the Apostle refuted, as Luke, who wrote the book as a history, tells us in the Acts of
the Apostles, “And certain also of the Epicurean and Stoic philosophers disputed with him.
And some said, What does this babbler mean? And others said, He seemeth to be a setter
forth of new gods.”268
22. Yet from this hand too the Apostle did not go forth without success, since even Di-
onysius the Areopagite together with his wife Damaris and many others believed. And so
that company of most learned and eloquent men showed themselves overcome in a simple
discussion by the example of those who believed. What then do those men mean, who en-
deavour to prevent those whom the Apostle has gained, and whom Christ has redeemed
with His own blood? asserting that the baptized ought not to give themselves to the discipline
of the virtues, that revellings injure them not, nor abundance of pleasures; that they are
267 Demarchus is mentioned by no writer besides St. Ambrose. The Benedictine editors suggest that Hermachus
is meant, who succeeded Epicurus as leader of his school.
268 Acts xvii. 18.
970
Epistle LXIII: To the Church at Vercellæ.