of men’s minds, and are more apt to be regarded as if they were all, or at least as some re-
semblance of the universal system.
Thus I have observed how many of these natural principles resemble virtue in its primary
operation, which is benevolence. Many of them also have a resemblance of it in its secondary
operation, which is its approbation of and complacence in virtue itself. Several kinds of ap-
probation of virtue, are not of the nature of a truly virtuous approbation, consisting in a
sense and relish of the essential beauty of virtue. As particularly, the approbation of con-
science, from a sense of the inferior and secondary beauty which there is in virtue, consisting
in uniformity; and from a sense of desert, consisting in a sense of the natural agreement of
loving and being beloved, showing kindness and receiving kindness. So, from the same
principle, there is a disapprobation of vice, from a natural opposition to deformity and dis-
proportion; and a sense of evil desert, or the natural agreement there is between hating and
being hated, opposing and being opposed, &c. together with a painful sensation naturally
arising from a sense of self-opposition and inconsistence. Approbation of conscience is the
more readily mistaken for a truly virtuous approbation, because by the wise constitution of
the great Governor of the world, when conscience is well informed, and thoroughly awakened,
it agrees with him fully and exactly, as to the object approved, though not as to the ground
and reason of approving. It approves all virtue, and condemns all vice. It approves true virtue,
and indeed approves nothing that is against it, or that falls short of it; as was shown before.
Natural conscience is implanted in all mankind, to be as it were in God’s stead, as internal
judge or rule, whereby to distinguish right and wrong.
It has also been observed, how that virtue, consisting in benevolence, is approved; and
vice, consisting in ill will, is disliked; from the influence of self-love, together with the asso-
ciation of ideas. In the same manner, men dislike those qualities in things without life or
reason, with which they have always connected the ideas of hurtfulness, malignancy, perni-
ciousness; but approve those things with which they habitually connect the ideas of profit,
pleasantness, &c. This approbation of virtue, and dislike of vice, is easily mistaken for true
virtue, not only because those things are approved by it that have the nature of virtue, and
the things disliked have the nature of vice; but because here is a great resemblance of virtuous
approbation, it being complacence from love; the difference only lying in this, that it is not
from love to being in general, but from self-love.
There is also, as before shown, a liking of some virtues, and a dislike of some vices, from
the influence of the natural instinct of pity. This we are apt to mistake for the exercise of
true virtue on many accounts. Here is not only a kind of complacence, and the objects of
complacence have the nature of virtue, and the virtues themselves are very amiable, such
as humanity, mercy, tenderness of heart, &c. and the contrary very odious; but besides, the
approbation is not merely from self-love, but from compassion; an affection that respects
others, and resembles benevolence, as before explained.
910
CHAPTER VII. The reasons of many mistakes