15. You say that you are not
the defender or the champion of Origen; but I will at once confront you
with your own book of which you spoke in that notorious preface to your
renowned work in these terms:
“The cause of this
diversity I have set forth more fully for you in the Apology which
Pamphilus wrote among his treatises, adding a very short document of my
own, in which I have shewn by what appear to me evident proofs, that
his works have been depraved in many places by heretics and
ill-disposed persons, and especially those which I am now translating,
the
Περὶ
᾽Αρχῶν
.”
The defence made by Eusebius, or
if you will have it so, by Pamphilus, was not sufficient for you, but
you must add something from your superior wisdom and learning to supply
what you thought insufficient in what they had said. It would be a long
business if I were to insert the whole of your book into the present
treatise, and, after setting out each paragraph, to reply to each in
turn, and shew what vices there are in the style, what falsehoods in
the assertions, what inconsistency in the actual tissue of the
language. And therefore, to avoid a redundant discussion which is
distasteful to me, I will compress the verbal matter into a narrow
compass, and reply to the meaning alone. As soon as he leaves the
harbour he runs his ship upon a rock. He recalls the words of the
Apology of the Martyr Pamphilus (which however, I have proved to be the
work of Eusebius the Chief of the Arians) of which he had said,
“I translated it into the Latin tongue as best I was able and as
the matter demanded;” he then adds: “It is this as to which
I wish to give you a charge, Macarius, man of desires,
3116
that you may feel sure that this rule of
faith which I have above set forth out of his books, is such as ought
to be embraced and held fast: it is clearly shewn that there is a
catholic meaning in them all.” Although he took away many things
from the book of Eusebius, and tried to alter in a good sense the
expressions about the Son and the Holy Spirit, still there are found in
it many causes of offence, and even open blasphemies, which our friend
cannot refuse to accept since he pronounces them to be catholic.
Eusebius (or, if you please, Pamphilus) says in that book that the Son
is the Servant of the Father, the Holy Spirit is not of the same
substance with the Father and the Son; that the souls of men have
fallen from heaven; and, inasmuch as we have been changed from the
state of Angels, that in the restitution of all things angels and
devils and men will all be equal; and many other things so impious and
atrocious that it would be a crime even to repeat them. The champion of
Origen and translator of Pamphilus is in a strange position. If there
is so much blasphemy in these parts which he has corrected, what
sacrilegious things must there be in the parts which, as he pretends,
have been falsified by heretics! What makes him hold this opinion, as
he says, is that a man who is neither a fool nor a madman could not
have said things mutually repugnant; and, that we may not suppose that
he had written different things at different times, and that he put
forth contrary views according to the time of writing, he has
added:
“What are we to say when
sometimes in the same place, and, so to speak, almost in the following
paragraph, a sentence with an opposite meaning is found inserted? Can
we believe that, in the same work and in the same book, and sometimes,
as I have said in the sentence immediately following, he can have
forgotten his own words? For example, could he who had before said, we
can find no passage throughout the Scriptures in which the Holy Spirit
is said to be created or made, immediately add that the Holy Spirit was
made among the rest of the creatures? or again, could he who defined
the Father and the Son to be of one substance, that namely which is
called in Greek Homoousion, say in the following portions that he was
of another substance, and that he was created, when but a little before
he had declared him to be born from the nature of God the
Father?”
3116
Taken from
Daniel x. 11
, “Thou man
greatly beloved” (“a man of desires”).