The genuineness
of this epistle is, to say the least, open to grave suspicion.
Jaffé (Regesta Pont. Lit. Spur.) rejects it as
spurious. Its style in some parts reminds us of Gregory, and it
contains passages identical with what he had written elsewhere:
but its prolixity, bad composition, and repetitions are unworthy of his
pen. It reads like an unskilful imitation of his style. Nor
is it difficult to understand why such a letter may have been
forged. If, as supposed in our note to Ep. XVI., a letter from
Sicily had been addressed to Gregory not long before his death with
reference to his answers to Augustine’s questions, to which
letter he had been unable to reply, it was not unlikely that such a
letter as the one before us would afterwards be composed in his
name. For anxiety might naturally be felt to vindicate from
inconsistency the teaching of the Roman See on the subject of marriages
of consanguinity. Such a letter, too, if forged, would be likely
to attempt an imitation of Gregory’s style, and to bring in (as
this does) extracts from his previous writings. It may be
observed that the plea set forth of the directions to Augustine having
been meant only as temporary concessions is not borne out by the actual
language of those directions. See XI. 64.