330 JEROME.
within their own communion. That is to say,
with senseless cruelty they would have surren-
dered the whole world to the devil. Why
condemn those who were not Arians? Why
rend the Church when it was continuing in
the harmony of the faith ? Lastly, were they
by obstinacy to make Arians of orthodox believers ? We know that at the Council of
Nicaea, which was assembled on account of the
Arian perfidy, eight Arian bishops were wel-
comed, and there is not a bishop in the world
at the present day whose ordination is not de-
pendent on that Council. This being so, how
could they act in opposition to it, when their
loyalty to it had cost them the pain of exile ?
20. L. Were Arians really then received
after all ? Pray tell me who they were.
O. 1 Eusebius, bishop of Nicomedia, a The- ognis, bishop of Nicaea, Saras, at the time
presbyter of Libya, 3 Eusebius, bishop of Csesarea in Palestine, and others whom it
would be tedious to enumerate ; Arius also,
the presbyter, the original source of all the
trouble ; Euzoius the deacon, 4 who suc- ceeded Eudoxius as bishop of Antioch, and
Achillas, the reader. These three who were
clerics of the Church of Alexandria were the
originators of the heresy.
L. Suppose a person were to deny that
they were welcomed back, how is he to be refuted ?
O. There are men still living who took part
in that Council. And if that is not enough,
because owing to the time that has elapsed
they are but few, and it is impossible for wit-
nesses to be everywhere, if we read the acts
and names of the bishops of the Council of
Nicaea, we find that those who we saw just
now were welcomed back, did subscribe the
homoousion along with the rest.
L. Will you point out how, after the Council
of Nicaea, they relapsed into their unfaithful- ness ?
O. A good suggestion, for unbelievers are
in the habit of shutting their eyes and deny-
ing that things which they dislike ever hap-
pened. But how could they afterwards do
anything but relapse, when it was owing to
1 Said to have been the "most prominent and most distin-
guished man of the entire movement." Athanasius suggested that he was the teacher rather than the disciple of Arius. He died A. D. 342.
2 Regarded as one of the chief opponents of Athanasius. He
and others it is said saved themselves from exile by secretly
substituting o/aotoiio-ios for 6/otoovo-ios in the sentence of the Council.
3 Born, probably, about A. D. 260. He was made bishop of Caesarea about 313 and lived to be eighty. At the time of the
Council he was the most learned man and most famous living writer. He had great influence with Constantino, and was
among the most moderate Arians.
4 Eudoxius was deposed from the bishopric of Antioch by the Council of Seleucia, A. D. 359 ; but the immediate predeces- sor of Euzoius was Meletius, deposed A. D. 361. Baronius describes him as the worst of all the Arians. Euzoius had been
the companion and intimate friend of Arius from an early age.
Athanasius (Hist. Arian. p. 858; calls him the " Canaanite."
them that the Council was convened, and their
letters and impious treatises which were pub-
lished before the Council, remain even to the
present day ? Seeing, therefore, that at that
time three hundred bishops or more welcomed
a few men whom they might have rejected
without injury to the Church, I am surprised
that certain persons, who are certainly uphold-
ers of the faith of Nicaea, are so harsh as to
think that ' three Confessors returning from exile were not bound in the interests of the
world's salvation to do what so many illustri- ous men did of their own accord. But, to go
back to our starting point, on the return of
the Confessors it was determined, in a synod
afterwards 3 held at Alexandria, that, the authors of the heresy excepted (who could not
be excused on the ground of error), penitents should be admitted to communion with the
Church : not that they who had been heretics
could be bishops, but because it was clear that
those who were received had not been heretics.
The West assented to this decision, and it was
through this conclusion, which the necessities
of the times demanded, that the world was
snatched from the jaws of Satan. I have
reached a very difficult subject, where I am
compelled against my wishes and my purpose,
to think somewhat otherwise of that saintly
man Lucifer than his merits demand, and my
own courtesy requires. But what am I to do ?
Truth opens my mouth and urges my reluctant
tongue to utter the thoughts of my heart. At
such a crisis of the Church, when the wolves
were wildly raging, he separated off a few
sheep and abandoned the remnant of the
flock. He himself was a good shepherd, but he
was leaving a vast spoil to the beasts of prey.
I take no notice of reports originating with
certain evil speakers, though maintained by
them to be authenticated facts ; such as that
he acted thus through the love of glory, and the
desire of handing down his name to posterity ;
or again that he was influenced by the grudge
he bore against Eusebius on account of the
3 quarrel at Antioch. 1 believe none of these reports in the case of such a man ; and this
I will constantly affirm even now — that the difference between us and him is one of words,
not of things, if he really does receive those
who have been baptized by the Arians.
21. L. The account I used before to hear
given of these things was widely different, and,
as I now think, better calculated to promote
error than hope. But I thank Christ my God
for pouring into my heart the light of truth,
that I might no longer profanely call the
1 Saints Athanasius, Hilary of Poictiers, and Eusebius of
Vercellae.
2 A. D. 328, when Athanasius was consecrated bishop. 3 See introduction.