For let us assume as granted what the system of our opponents demands, that the having
no generation is Being, and in like manner again that generation is admitted into Being. If,
then, one were to follow out carefully these statements in all their meaning, even this way
the Manichæan heresy will be reconstructed seeing that the Manichees are wont to take as
an axiom the oppositions of good and bad, light and darkness, and all such naturally antag-
onistic things. I think that any who will not be satisfied with a superficial view of the matter
will be convinced that I say true. Let us look at it thus. Every subject has certain inherent
characteristics, by means of which the specialty of that underlying nature is known. This is
so, whether we are investigating the animal kingdom, or any other. The tree and the animal
are not known by the same marks; nor do the characteristics of man extend in the animal
kingdom to the brutes; nor, again, do the same symptoms indicate life and death; in every
case, without exception, as we have said, the distinction of subjects resists any effort to
confuse them and run one into another; the marks upon each thing which we observe cannot
be communicated so as to destroy that distinction. Let us follow this out in examining our
opponents’ position. They say that the state of having no generation is Being; and they
likewise make the having generation Being. But just as a man and a stone have not the same
marks (in defining the essence of the animate and that of the inanimate you would not give
the same account of each), so they must certainly grant that one who is non-generated is to
be known by different signs to the generated. Let us then survey those peculiar qualities of
the non-generated Deity, which the Holy Scriptures teach us can be mentioned and thought
of, without doing Him an irreverence.
What are they? I think no Christian is ignorant that He is good, kind, holy, just and
hallowed, unseen and immortal, incapable of decay and change and alteration, powerful,
wise, beneficent, Master, Judge, and everything like that. Why lengthen our discussion by
lingering on acknowledged facts? If, then, we find these qualities in the ungenerate nature,
and the state of having been generated is contrary182 in its very conception to the state of
having not been generated, those who define these two states to be each of them Being, must
perforce concede, that the characteristic marks of the generated being, following this oppos-
ition existing between the generated and non-generated, must be contrary to the marks
observable in the non-generated being; for if they were to declare the marks to be the same,
83
this sameness would destroy the difference between the two beings who are the subject of
these observations. Differing things must be regarded as possessing differing marks; like
things are to be known by like signs. If, then, these men testify to the same marks in the
Only-begotten, they can conceive of no difference whatever in the subject of the marks. But
if they persist in their blasphemous position, and maintain in asserting the difference of the
182 ὑπεναντίως, i.e. as logical “contraries” differ from each other. This is not an Aristotelian, but a Neo-Pla-
tonic use of the word (i.e. Ammonius, a.d. 390, &c.). It occurs so again in this Book frequently.
157
Proof that the Anomœan teaching tends to Manichæism.