AGAINST THE PELAGIANS.— BOOK III. 477
though I be nothing." Peter, disturbed by the greatness of the miracles he witnessed,
said to the Lord,1 " Depart from me, for I am
a sinful man." And the Lord said to His
disciples, 2 " I am the vine and ye are the branches : He that abideth in Me and I in
him, the same beareth much fruit, for apart
from Me ye can do nothing." Just as the vine branches and shoots immediately decay
when they are severed from the parent stem,
so all the strength of men fades and perishes,
if it be bereft of the help of God. " No
one,"3 He says, " can come unto Me except
the Father Who sent Me draw him." When
He says, 4< No one can come unto Me," He shatters the pride of free will ; because, even
if a man will to go to Christ, except that be,
realized which follows — "unless My heavenly
Father draw him" — desire is to no purpose, and effort is in vain. At the same time it is
to be noted that he who is drawn does not
run freely, but is led along either because he
holds back and is sluggish, or because he is
reluctant to go.
10. Now, how can a man who cannot by his
own strength and labour come to Jesus, at the same time avoid all sins? and avoid thefn
perpetually, and claim for himself a name
which belongs to the might of God ? For if
He and I are both without sin, what differ- ence is there between me and God ? One
more proof only I will adduce, that I may not
weary you and my hearers. 4 Sleep was removed from the eyes of Ahasuerus, whom
the Seventy call Artaxerxes, that he might turn over the memoirs of his faithful ministers and
come upon Mordecai, by whose evidence he
was delivered from a conspiracy ; and that
thus Esther might be more acceptable, and the
whole people of the Jews escape imminent
death. There is no doubt that the mighty
sovereign to whom belonged the whole East,
from India to the North and to Ethiopia,
after feasting sumptuously on delicacies
gathered from every part of the world would
have desired to sleep, and to take his rest,
and to gratify his free choice of sleep, had
not the Lord, the provider of all good things,
hindered the course of nature, so that in
defiance of nature the tyrant's cruelty might be overcome. If I were to attempt to pro-
duce all the instances in Holy Writ, I should
be tedious. All that the saints say is a prayer
to God ; their whole prayer and supplication
a strong wrestling for the pity of God, so
that we, who by our own strength and zeal
cannot be saved, may be preserved by His
mercy. But when we are concerned with
grace and mercy, free will is in part void ;
' S. Luke y. 8. 4 Either vi. i. » S. John xv. 5. * S. John vi. 44.
in part, I say, for so much as this depends
upon it, that we wish and desire, and give
assent to the course we choose. But it de-
pends on God whether we have the power in
His strength and with His help to perform
what we desire, and to bring to effect our toil and effort.
ii. C. I simply said that we find the help
of God not in our several actions, but in the
grace of creation and of the law, that free
will might not be destroyed. But there are
many of us who maintain that all we do is
done with the help of God.
A. Whoever says that must leave your
party. Either, then, say the same yourself and
join our side, or, if you refuse, you will be just
as much our enemy as those who do not hold our views.
C. I shall be on your side if you speak my
sentiments, or rather you will be on mine if
you do not contradict them. You admit
health of body, and deny health of the soul,
which is stronger than the body. For sin is to the soul what disease or a wound is to the
body. If then you admit that a man may be
healthy so far as he is flesh, why do you
not say he may be healthy so far as he is
spirit ?
A. I will follow in 'the line you point out, " and you to-day
"Shall ne'er escape ; where'er you call, I come."
C. I am ready to listen.
A. And I to speak to deaf ears. I will
therefore reply to your argument. Made up
of soul and body, we have the nature of both
substances. As the body is said to be healthy
if it is troubled with no weakness, so the
soul is free from fault if it is unshaken and
undisturbed. And yet, although the body
may be healthy, sound, and active, with all
the faculties in their full vigour, yet it suffers
much from infirmities at more or less fre-
quent intervals, and, however strong it may
be, is sometimes distressed by various hu-
mours ; so the soul, bearing the onset of
thoughts and agitations, even though it es-
cape shipwreck, does not sail without danger,
and remembering its weakness, is always
anxious about death, according as it is written,
1 " What man is he that shall live and not
see death ?" — death, which threatens all mortal
men, not through the decay of nature, but
through the death of sin, according to the
prophet's words," " The soul that sinneth, it
shall die." Besides, we know that Enoch and Elias have not yet seen this death which is common to man and the brutes. Show me
a body which is never sick, or which after
sickness is ever safe and sound, and I will
1 Ps. Ixxxix. 48. 1 Ezek. xviii. 4.