O. A good suggestion, for unbelievers are in the habit
of shutting their eyes and denying that things which they dislike ever
happened. But how could they afterwards do anything but relapse, when
it was owing to them that the Council was convened, and their letters
and impious treatises which were published before the Council, remain
even to the present day? Seeing, therefore, that at that time three
hundred bishops or more welcomed a few men whom they might have
rejected without injury to the Church, I am surprised that certain
persons, who are certainly upholders of the faith of Nicæa, are so
harsh as to think that Saints Athanasius,
Hilary of Poictiers, and Eusebius of Vercellae.three Confessors
returning from exile were not bound in the interests of the
world’s salvation to do what so many illustrious men did of their
own accord. But, to go back to our starting point, on the return of the
Confessors it was determined, in a synod afterwards a.d. 328, when Athanasius was consecrated bishop. held at Alexandria, that, the authors
of the heresy excepted (who could not be excused on the ground of
error), penitents should be admitted to communion with the Church: not
that they who had been heretics could be bishops, but because it was
clear that those who were received had not been heretics. The West
assented to this decision, and it was through this conclusion, which
the necessities of the times demanded, that the world was snatched from
the jaws of Satan. I have reached a very difficult subject, where I am
compelled against my wishes and my purpose, to think somewhat otherwise
of that saintly man Lucifer than his merits demand, and my own courtesy
requires. But what am I to do? Truth opens my mouth and urges my
reluctant tongue to utter the thoughts of my heart. At such a crisis of
the Church, when the wolves were wildly raging, he separated off a few
sheep and abandoned the remnant of the flock. He himself was a good
shepherd, but he was leaving a vast spoil to the beasts of prey. I take
no notice of reports originating with certain evil speakers, though
maintained by them to be authenticated facts; such as that he acted
thus through the love of glory, and the desire of handing down his name
to posterity; or again that he was influenced by the grudge he bore
against Eusebius on account of the See
introduction.quarrel
at Antioch. I believe none of these reports in the case of such a man;
and this I will constantly affirm even now—that the difference
between us and him is one of words, not of things, if he really does
receive those who have been baptized by the Arians.