Chapter 14.—19. But which is the worse, not to be baptized at all, or to be twice baptized,
it is difficult to decide. I see, indeed, which is more repugnant and abhorrent to men’s
feelings; but when I have recourse to that divine balance, in which the weight of things is
determined, not by man’s feelings, but by the authority of God, I find a statement by our
Lord on either side. For He said to Peter, "He who is washed has no need of washing a
second time;"1261 and to Nicodemus, "Except a man be born of water and of the Spirit, he
cannot enter into the kingdom of God."1262 What is the purport of the more secret determ-
ination of God, it is perhaps difficult for men like us to learn; but as far as the mere words
are concerned, any one may see what a difference there is between "has no need of washing,"
and "cannot enter into the kingdom of heaven." The Church, lastly, herself holds as her
tradition, that without baptism she cannot admit a man to her altar at all; but since it is al-
lowed that one who has been rebaptized may be admitted after penance, surely this plainly
proves that his baptism is considered valid. If, therefore, Cyprian thought that those whom
he considered to be unbaptized yet had some share in pardon, in virtue of the bond of unity,
the Lord has power to be reconciled even to the rebaptized by means of the simple bond of
unity and peace, and by this same compensating power of peace to mitigate His displeasure
against those by whom they were rebaptized, and to pardon all the errors which they had
committed while in error, on their offering the sacrifice of charity, which covereth the
multitude of sins; so that He looks not to the number of those who have been wounded by
their separation, but to the greater number who have been delivered from bondage by their
return. For in the same bond of peace in which Cyprian conceived that, through the mercy
of God, those whom he considered to have been admitted to the Church without baptism,
were yet not severed from the gifts of the Church, we also believe that through the same
mercy of God the rebaptized can earn their pardon at His hands.
1261 John xiii. 10. "Qui lotus est, non habet necessitatem iterum lavandi." The Latin, with the A.V., loses the
distinction between ὁ λελουμένος, "he that has bathed," and νίπτειν, "to wash:" and further wrongfully introduces
the idea of repetition.
1262 John iii. 5.
Chapter 14
750
Chapter 14