Now of course nobody supposes for a moment that
Charlemagne wrote these books himself. But Sir William Palmer
(Treatise on the Church, Vol. II., p. 204) says that the
prelates of the realm of France “composed a reply to this
Synod,” he further says that “This work was published by
the authority and in the name of the Emperor Charlemagne and with the
consent of his bishops, in 790” (p. 205). I am entirely at
a loss to know on what authority these statements rest. The
authorship of the work has not without great show of reason, been
attributed to Alcuin. Besides the English tradition that he had
written such a book, there has been pointed out the remarkable
similarity of his commentary on St. John (4, 5, et seqq.) to a
passage in Liber IV., cap. vj., of these Caroline Books. (On this
point see Forster, General Preface to the Works of Alcuin n.
10.) But after all whether Alcuin was the author or no, matters
little, the statement that the “bishops of France” were in
any sense responsible for it is entirely gratuitous, unless indeed some
should think it may be gathered from the statement of the Preface;