doctrine,1554 but that each one should continue to hold what he believed. For he asserted
that those who trusted in the Crucified would be saved, if only they were found doing good
works.1555 But as we have said before, his opinion concerning God was the most obscure
of all. For he spoke of one principle, as also our doctrine does.”
6. Then, after stating fully his own opinion, he adds:
“When I said to him, Tell me how you know this or how can you assert that there is one
principle, he replied that the prophecies refuted themselves, because they have said nothing
true;1556 for they are inconsistent, and false, and self-contradictory. But how there is one
principle he said that he did not know, but that he was thus persuaded.
the great difference between himself and the Gnostics. Marcion did not leave the Church until he was obliged
to, and he founded his own church only under compulsion, upon being driven out of the Catholic community.
1554 τὸν λόγον.
1555 This is a truly Christian sentiment, and Apelles should be honored for the expression of it. It reveals
clearly the religious character of Marcionism in distinction from the speculative and theological character of
the Gnostics, and indeed of many of the Fathers. With Marcion and Apelles we are in a world of sensitive moral
principle and of deep religious feeling like that in which Paul and Augustine lived, but few others in the early
Church. Rhodo, in spite of his orthodoxy, shows himself the real Gnostic over against the sincere believer, though
the latter was in the eyes of the Church a “blasphemous heretic.” Apelles’ noble words do honor to the move-
ment—however heretical it was—which in that barren age of theology could give them birth. The latter clause,
taken as it stands, would seem to indicate an elevation of good works to the level of faith; but though it is possible
that Apelles may have intended to express himself thus, it is more probable, when we remember the emphasis
which Marcion laid upon Paul’s doctrine of salvation by the grace of God alone, that he meant to do no more
than emphasize good works as a natural result of true faith, as we do to-day. The apparent co-ordination of the
two may perhaps lie simply in Rhodo’s reproduction of Apelles’ words. He, at least, did not comprehend Paul’s
grand doctrine of Christian liberty, nor did any of his orthodox contemporaries. The difference between the
common conception of Christ’s relation to the law, and the conception of Paul as grasped by Marcion and perhaps
by Apelles, is well illustrated by a passage in Tertullian, in which he expresses astonishment that the Marcionites
do not sin freely, so long as they do not expect to be punished, and exclaims (to his own dishonor), “I would sin
without scruple, if I believed as you do.”
1556 Rhodo had probably brought forward against Apelles proof from prophecy which led to the discussion
of the Old Testament prophecies in general. Although Apelles had rejected Marcion’s dualism, and accepted
the “one principle,” he still rejected the Old Testament. This is quite peculiar, and yet perfectly comprehensible;
for while Marcion was indeed the only one of that age that understood Paul, yet as Harnack well says, even he
misunderstood him; and neither himself nor his followers were able to rise to Paul’s noble conception of the
Old Testament law as a “schoolmaster to bring us to Christ,” and thus a part of the good God’s general plan of
salvation. It took, perhaps, a born Jew, as Paul was, to reach that high conception of the law in those days. To
Marcion and his followers the law seemed to stand in irreconcilable conflict with the Gospel,—Jewish law on
the one side, Gospel liberty on the other,—they could not reconcile them; they must, therefore, reject the former
537
Rhodo and his Account of the Dissension of Marcion.