He says, “If
‘Father’ is the same in meaning as
‘Ungenerate,’ and words which have the same meaning
naturally have in every respect the same force, and Ungenerate
signifies by their confession that God comes from nothing, it follows
necessarily that Father signifies the fact of God being of none, and
not the having generated the Son.” Now what is this logical
necessity which prevents the having generated a Son being signified by
the title “Father,” if so be that that same title does in
itself express to us as well the absence of beginning in the Father?
If, indeed, the one idea was totally destructive of the other, it would
certainly follow, from the very nature of contradictories κατὰ τὴν τῶν
ἀντικειμένων
φύσιν. If
᾽Αγέννητος
means not having a son, then to affirm
‘God is always ᾽Αγέννητος’ is even to deny (its logical contradictory)
‘God once had a Son.’, that the affirming of the one would involve
the denial of the other. But if there is nothing in the world to
prevent the same Existence from being Father and also Ungenerate, when we try
to think, under this title of Father, of the quality of not having been
generated as one of the ideas implied in it, what necessity prevents
the relation to a Son being any longer marked by the word Father? Other
names which express mutual relationship are not always confined to
those ideas of relationship; for instance, we call the emperor τὸν
βασιλέα. autocrat and masterless, and we call the same
the ruler of his subjects; and, while it is quite true that the word
emperor signifies also the being masterless, it is not therefore
necessary that this word, because signifying autocratic and unruled,
must cease to imply the having power over inferiors; the word emperor,
in fact, is midway between these two conceptions, and at one time
indicates masterlessness, at another the ruling over lower orders. In
the case before us, then, if there is some other Father conceivable
besides the Father of Our Lord, let these men who boast of their
profound wisdom show him to us, and then we will agree with him that
the idea of the Ungenerate cannot be represented by the title
“Father.” But if the First Father has no cause transcending
His own state, and the subsistence of the Son is invariably implied in
the title of Father, why do they try to scare us, as if we were
children, with these professional twistings of premisses, endeavouring
to persuade or rather to decoy us into the belief that, if the property
of not having been generated is acknowledged in the title of Father, we
must sever from the Father any relation with the Son.