In the
chapter in which Professor Ramsay discusses the story of Glycerius
he asks how it was that, while Phrygia was heretical, Cappadocia, in
the fourth century, was orthodox: “Can any reason be
suggested why this great Cappadocian leader followed the Roman
Church, whereas all the most striking figures in Phrygian
ecclesiastical history opposed it?” In Phrygia was the
great centre of Montanism, a form of religionism not unfavourable to
excesses such as those of Glycerius. But in Letter
cciv., placed in 375, Basil claims both the Phrygias, i.e.
Pacatiana and Salutaris, as being in communion with him.
By the “Roman Church,” followed by Cappadocia and
opposed by Phrygia, must be meant either the ecclesiastical system
of the Roman Empire, or the Church at Rome regarded as holding a
kind of hegemony of Churches. If the former, it will be
remembered that Cappadocia boldly withstood the creed patronized and
pressed by imperial authority, when the influence of Valens made
Arianism the official religion of Rome. If the latter, the
phrase seems a misleading anachronism. In the fourth century
there was no following or opposing the Church of Rome as we
understand the phrase. To the bishop of Rome was conceded a
certain personal precedence, as bishop of the capital, and he was
beginning to claim more. In the West there was the dignity of
the only western apostolic see, and the Church of Rome, as a
society, was eminently orthodox and respectable. But, as
important ecclesiastical centres, Antioch and Alexandria were far
ahead of Rome, and the pope of Alexandria occupied a greater place
than the pope of Rome. What Basil was eager to follow was not
any local church, but the Faith which he understood to be the true
and Catholic Faith, i.e., the Faith of Nicæa.
There was no church of Rome in the sense of one organized
œcumenical society governed by a central Italian
authority. Basil has no idea of any such thing as a Roman
supremacy. cf. Letter ccxiv. and note.