blame, rewards and punishments: strictly examining the modern notions of these things,
endeavouring to demonstrate their most palpable inconsistency and absurdity; endeavouring
also to bring the late great objections and outcries against Calvinistic divinity, from these
topics, to the test of the strictest reasoning; and particularly that great objection, in which
the modern writers have so much gloried, so long triumphed, with so great a degree of insult
towards the most excellent divines, and in effect against the gospel of Jesus Christ:—viz.
That the Calvinistic notions of God’s moral government are contrary to the common sense
of mankind. In this Essay, I propose to take particular notice of the writings of Dr. Whitby,
and Mr. Chubb, and the writings of some others, who, though not properly Pelagians, nor
Arminians, yet in their notions of the freedom of the will, have, in the main, gone into the
same scheme. But, if I live to prosecute my design, I shall send you a more particular account
of my plan after it is perfected.
I suppose there has been a trial before now, whether a national collection can be obtained
in Scotland, for New Jersey college: unless it has been thought prudent, by such as are friends
of the affair, to put it off a year longer; as some things I have seen seem to argue. There was
a design of Mr. Pemberton’s going to England and Scotland. He was desired by the trustees,
cxlvi
and it was his settled purpose, to have gone the last year; but his people, and his colleague,
Mr. Cummings, hindered it. His intention of going occasioned great uneasiness among his
people, and created some dissatisfaction towards him, in the minds of some of them. Since
that President Burr has been desired to go, by the unanimous voice of the trustees. Never-
theless. I believe there is little probability of his consenting to it; partly, on the account of
his having lately entered into a married state. On the 29th of last month, he was married to
my third daughter.
What you write of the appointment of a gentleman, to the office of lieut. governour, of
Virginia, who is a friend of religion, is an event that the friends of religion in America have
great reason to rejoice in; by reason of the late revival of religion in that province, and the
opposition that has been made against it, and the great endeavours to crush it, by many of
the chief men of the province. Mr. Davies, in a letter I lately received from him, dated March
2, 1752, mentions the same thing. His words are, ‘we have a new governor; who is a candid,
condescending gentleman. And, as he has been educated in the church of Scotland, he has
a respect for the Presbyterians; which I hope is a happy omen.’ I was in the latter part of the
last summer applied to, with much earnestness and importunity, by some of the people of
Virginia, to come and settle among them, in the work of the ministry; who subscribed
handsomely for my encouragement and support, and sent a messenger to me with their re-
quest and subscriptions; but I was installed at Stockbridge before the messenger came I have
written some account of the state of things at Stockbridge to Mr. M’Laurin; which you
doubtless will have opportunity to see.
303
CHAPTER XX. Letter to Sir W. Pepperell. Letter to Lady Pepperell. Letter…