This is probably the earliest distinct and formal statement of the
descent into Hades; but no special stress is laid upon it as a new
doctrine, and it is stated so much as a matter of course as to show
that it was commonly accepted at Edessa at the time of the writing of
these records, that is certainly as early as the third century. Justin,
Irenæus, Clement of Alexandria, Origen, Tertullian, &c., all
witness to the belief of the Church in this doctrine, though it did not
form an article in any of the older creeds, and appeared in the East
first in certain Arian confessions at about 360 a.d. In the West it appeared first in the Aquileian creed,
from which it was transferred to the Apostles’ creed in the fifth
century or later.
The doctrine is stated
in a very fantastic shape in the Gospel of Nicodemus, part II.
(Ante-Nicene Fathers, Am. ed. VIII. p. 435 sq.), which is based
upon an apocryphal gospel of the second century, according to
Tischendorf. In it the descent of Christ into Hades and his ascent with
a great multitude are dwelt upon at length. Compare Pearson, On the
Creed, p. 340 sq.; Schaff’s Creeds of Christendom, I.
p. 46; and especially, Plumptre’s Spirits in Prison, p. 77
sq.