That Dionysius in his ‘Refutation and
Defence’ merely restated, and did not (κατ᾽
οἰκονομίαν)
alter, his theological position is open to no doubt. Athanasius, not
the Arians, had the right to claim him as his own. He is clearly
speaking optima fide when he deprecates the pressing of
statements in which he had given expression to one side only, and that
the less essential side, of his convictions. At the same time we cannot
but see that the Arians had good prima facie ground for their
appeal. Here were their special formulæ, those anathematised at
Nicæa, ἦν
ποτὲ ὅτε οὐκ
ἦν and the rest, adopted, and the ὁμοούσιον
implicitly rejected, by the most renowned bishop Alexandria had yet
had. (Newman, in de Decr. 26, note 7, fails to appreciate the
reference to the language of Dion. Alex.) Moreover it is only fair to
admit that not only in language, but in thought also, Athanasius had
advanced upon his predecessors of the Alexandrian School. The rude
shock of Arianism had shewn him and the other Nicene leaders the
necessity of greater consistency than had characterised the theology of
Origen and his school, a consistency to be gained only by breaking with
one side of it altogether. While on the one hand Origen held fast to
the Godhead of the Logos (κατ᾽
οὐσίαν ἐστὶ
θεὸς), and to His co-eternity with the
Father (ἀεὶ
γεννᾶται ὁ
σωτὴρ ὑπὸ
τοῦ πατρός, and
see de Decr. §27); he had yet, using οὐσία in its ‘first’
sense, spoken of Him as ἕτερος κατ᾽
οὐσίαν τοῦ
πατρός (de Orat. 15), and
placed him, after the manner of Philo, as an intermediary between God
and the Universe. He had spoken of the unity of the Father and the Son
as moral (Cels. viii. 12, τῇ
ὁμονοί& 139·
καὶ τῇ
συμφωνί& 139·),
insisted upon the ὑπεροχὴ of the Father (i.e.
‘subordination’ of the Son), and spoken (De Orat) as
though the highest worship of all were to be reserved for the Father
(Jerome ascribes still stronger language to him). Yet there is no real
doubt that, as regards the core of the question, Athanasius and not his
opponents is the true successor of Origen. The essential difference
between Athanasius and the ‘Conservatives’ of the period
following the great council consisted in the fact that the former saw
clearly what the latter failed to realise, namely the insufficiency of
the formulæ of the third century to meet the problem of the
fourth. We may then, without disparagement to Dionysius, admit that he
was not absolutely consistent in his language; that he failed to
distinguish the ambiguities which beset the words οὐσία, ὑπόστασις, and even
ποιεῖν and γένεσθαι, and that
he used language (οὐκ ἦν
πρὶν
γεννήθῃ and the like) which
we, with our minds cleared by the Arian controversy, cannot reconcile
with the more deliberate and guarded statements of the
‘Refutation and Defence It may
be added that the letter to Paul of Samosata quoted by Bull, Def. III.
iv. 3, Petavius, Trin. I. iv. is not genuine. Posterity, which
enveloped the name of Origen with storms of controversy, did not
entirely spare his pupil: Basil (Ep. 41) taxes him with sowing
the first seeds of the Anomœan heresy, Gennadius (Eccl.
Dogm. iv.) calls him ‘Fons Arii.’.’